Cover Girl Clump Crusher and Rimmel ScandalEyes Retro Glam are my favorte drugstore mascaras. I need the waterproof versions because I live in a humid area. The non-waterproof Retro Eyes was a total fail for me, but might work for someone who isn't in a humid area. The waterproof version has been very successful for me.
Thanks again to strait girl and others for all the recommendations. I love reading about ones that I haven't tried in a long time that I maybe want to give another try.
Quinny-I've been really happy with the Rimmel I'm currently using. I forget which one it is, but I will check and post back. I don't think that there are too many in the line (maybe 3-4??"), but I like this one.
Got it, ladies. I purchased the Mocha color--I haven't purchased a dark brown mascara in some time. But I generally have liked them. Not quite as dramatic as a black, but I'm hoping I love it. Thanks again for the suggestions. And since you all know I'm a fickle girl, I will be referring to this list next time I'm ready for another mascara. Oh, and I'll let you know how I like it once I do my face again in the morning.
Just tried Loreal Telescopic in the gold tube and it is awesome!!!
It has a comb applicator and I no longer have to order It Cosmetics tightline mascara as this applies way into the lash line and no clumping as you comb it through. I have very thinned out lashes and this is my new favorite.