I've really never felt the need for using this for aluminum foil. I don't have problems getting the foil off the roll, in the box. But I only use heavy-duty, so maybe that one is easier. I also hold out to get the one that is the regular length because I have a drawer into which all those fit well. The only long one I get is the Reynold's Parchment.
I'd be surprised if they came out with a longer one, though. That would be a pretty narrow market and to sell stuff on tv it needs to be way more widely desired than one might think.
I use that one that is shown for cellophane wrap. It makes it moderately easier to use the wrap, as opposed to pulling it from the box. But it's not the 'best thing ever' kind of thing that they would have you think.
Their presentations are amusing, though. They make it like there is no possible way that a mere human could ever pull any kind of wrap out of a box (like we all did for decades). hehe - it is funny how somebody will always grab a box and make a big mess out of it 'trying' to pull out the wrap. 