I recently dealt directly with the Dooney site and was not thrilled. I placed my order directly online thru their site with my e-mail log in and got the confirmation e-mail for my order. So far, so good. Then days later I followed up, signed on to the website, and there was NO RECORD of my order and no history of the past orders I placed at Christmas. I called customer service and she said, whoops, it had been delivered (and I was able to pick it up at my P.O. Box). I have had better luck with ILoveDooney for follow up and order history.
My current preference is to just wait till they have a sale at Macys and deal with them online. I can always take returns directly to the store.