Really, I'm a neatnik (of sorts), but there is just not enough storage for bathroom things. So, some of it is hanging out.
A cosmetic bag for pencils, brushes and odds & ends - scissors, nail things - my 10x mirror sits on top of a 3 drawer plastic organizer. Can't I do any better than this? But some skin care things are out, too.
But then, you ought to see my office, not really disorganized, just....things that I can easily reach and way too many yellow sticky notes.