Just to be clear, Jennifer Aniston has 3 fragrances. It's her first release that is in a clear glass bottle with clear perfume.
I bought a bottle a year and a half ago that was still sealed in the package. I just opened it today and I'm more in love with it than ever. It has the softness of Amazing Grace but the soapy notes of Pure Grace (neroli, orange blossom). I actually like it better than both of them.
I'm so glad I saw this post! I had forgotten I had a bottle in the back of my cabinet (I have a huge collection of fragrances). So seeing the conversation about Pure Grace reminded me of the similarity. I hope you find it to be a good substitution, too.