Reply
Esteemed Contributor
Posts: 5,901
Registered: ‎03-10-2010

Yes, Allure magazine did an article about fake cosmetics - the focus was basically on fake EL brands like MAC. The irony of that article was that there wasn't one EL branded ad in the whole beauty magazine. Off topic but I wonder how much longer Allure magazine will be around as they seem to have lost a lot of print advertisers.

 

Anyway I don't buy from Amazon oe Ebay and have never bought makeup from a flea market. I prefer drug stores over department stores too. Sephora is OK for some things but I would not use the testers either. I won't let sales people touch my face no matter what beauty store or makeup counter I visit.

Honored Contributor
Posts: 36,345
Registered: ‎05-17-2010

@tototwo wrote:

Another story on the national news last night about fake makeup.  This is a big business on the East and West coasts mostly.  Packaging and colors look identical to high-end brands, but ingredients are dangerous and unsanitary.  These fakes are usually sold at discount markets like fairs or sidewalk shops, or online - not in brand-name stores.  Ladies think they are getting a bargain, but end up with skin and eye infections, rashes, etc., that require medical treatment.

 

I know this has been discussed on here before - this is just a reminder.

 

 


@tototwo  I go by my “retail rule”:  If an LV bag or Rolex watch or expensive cosmetic item is priced too low, it  makes me suspicious. Even if a bargain is to be had at a discount store from shampoo to cosmetics or perfume....No! How’d they end up there? Fake? Past the “use by” date? 

 

I’d rather pay more and deal only with reputable retailers/online sights. I know what I’m putting on my skin is the real deal.

 

 

 

Esteemed Contributor
Posts: 5,546
Registered: ‎02-02-2015

@tototwo wrote:

I would never buy cosmetics or skin care from Amazon or eBay either!


I won't either.  I also don't trust the dollar store for certain products.  

Honored Contributor
Posts: 24,685
Registered: ‎07-21-2011

Some so called "bargains" are not worth it.  I prefer to always buy my makeup from reputable cosmetic cos., dept. stores or drug stores.  Cat Very Happy   With the asbestos being recently in the news that it was in children's makeup is a scary thing.

kindness is strength
Respected Contributor
Posts: 2,671
Registered: ‎05-13-2017

Re: Fake Makeup

[ Edited ]

I've used the same brand (Ardell demi-pixie) false eyelashes since I was in my 20's.  I order them now from Ulta.  Last year I checked Amazon and there was a great deal - almost too good to be true.  I bought them.  "FAKE"!!!  They were paper thin and could not even get them to conform to my eye shape. All in the garbage. Lesson learned.

 

My all time favorite Eau de Parfum is "Shalimar".  It is sold for $135 across the board at Nordstrom, Saks, Neimans.... you get the idea.  A friend of mine loved the scent and proudly said she bought the same bottle of Shlimar for $56.00!  Well when she got it, I got out my bottle and we tested.  It was not Shalimar parfum at all, but a weak toilet water similar scent that dissipated quickly.  Shalimar hangs around in my closet for a few days after it's on my clothes.

 

 

Amazon is known for these practices just like ebay. BEWARE, there's no free lunch on certain items. You get what you pay for.Woman Happy

 

 

PS. Even on days when Saks, etc has "spend $200, get $50.00 off" it always excludes the fine french parfum houses.

 

Respected Contributor
Posts: 2,070
Registered: ‎03-13-2010

Fake Dior lipstick on Ebay, never again.  Too good to be true, should have known better.  Lesson learned

Deb

Valued Contributor
Posts: 949
Registered: ‎05-22-2010

Re: Fake Makeup

[ Edited ]

@Annabellethecat66 wrote:

I have 2 teenage granddaughters.  I buy them quality name brand makeup from QVC or Ulta.

 

But the one granddaughter is always on youtube watching those stupid how to's.  

 

They have flawless skin but I keep telling them that if they use some of this .99 drug store stuff their nice skin will not look that way much longer.

 

Teenagers are notorious for 'sharing' makeup.  I constantly am talking about how that is a no no....

 

 



That flawless skin is fake as well, they use heavy filtering on their videos. Wayne Goss blew up a Bobby Brown video regarding filtering.

Honored Contributor
Posts: 36,345
Registered: ‎05-17-2010

@TY wrote:

Yes, Allure magazine did an article about fake cosmetics - the focus was basically on fake EL brands like MAC. The irony of that article was that there wasn't one EL branded ad in the whole beauty magazine. Off topic but I wonder how much longer Allure magazine will be around as they seem to have lost a lot of print advertisers.

 

Anyway I don't buy from Amazon oe Ebay and have never bought makeup from a flea market. I prefer drug stores over department stores too. Sephora is OK for some things but I would not use the testers either. I won't let sales people touch my face no matter what beauty store or makeup counter I visit.


 

@TY  Re: Allure magazine. I think eventually all print magazines will only be available online. Unfortunely, it’s more expensive to print them, more people are reading everything online, books & newspapers, too, and advertisers are pulling out knowing their ads aren’t bring in business they’re paying for. 

 

Agree about not purchasing skincare/makeup from eBay, but Amazon will often state where the product is coming from...if a sight I’ve used in the past and a better price, I feel confident.

 

Also no testing cosmetics in any stores...department or Sephora, etc.! There have been case of serious infections transmitted through dirty lipstick/shadow testers (brushes, too) even in high end stores.

 

Bobbi Brown counter at Nordstrom sprayed alcohol & wiped across lipcolor I wanted to try. Other counters may follow. First time I’ve seen that. Was that adequate? Don’t know. Time will tell.

 

 

Trusted Contributor
Posts: 1,187
Registered: ‎03-09-2010

This is a very informative thread. I too have been disappointed by purchasing cosmetics on Amazon. I should have known better...Smiley Indifferent 

Open my heart and you will see, engraved inside, Italy - Robert Browning
Honored Contributor
Posts: 36,345
Registered: ‎05-17-2010

@tototwo wrote:

Well, I don't have any problem buying that ".99 drug store stuff" because, seriously, who's going to fake the cheap brands?   No profit there.  Just because some brands are more expensive doesn't mean they're better quality.  


 

 

@tototwo  Some brands or cosmetics that are more expensive are better. I find foundations are a better quality and more easily matched in dept. stores. I don’t trust .99 cent products near my eyes like liners or mascara. I do use drugstore L’oreal mascara, lipsticks, gloss, lotion/potions, etc.