@CrazyHolidayGuy
I had an item like that delivered last year & they DID indeed give me credit.
Mine was a set so I received partial credit because only one piece was broken.
I probably could have received full credit but I was happy with partial & wanted to be fair to QVC also.
Anyways, I ended up gluing the broken piece. It's not perfect but I disguise it like you are contemplating.
I would suggest - on a hollow item like you are showing - to stuff some foam, tissues or paper towels in there to "sturdy it up".
You also may be able to find some red duct type tape to cover the hole & again - keep it from breaking more.
Good luck!!!