Beauty

[Quinny]

I'm on the hunt for a bronze (preferably gel) waterproof eyeliner pencil.  I just used up the last of my 5 pencil stash of  Urban Decay's discontinued bronze eyeliner pencil.  

I tried a Tarte bronze eyeliner 

I tried a Rimmel Bronze eyeliner pencil 

I'd appreciate any suggestions. 

[Brisky]

Have you looked at Bobbie Brown's site?
What is your eye color? Mine is blue and when I put Bronze on they pop big time.

[Brisky]

Try Sephora or ulta. Many there! HTH.

[Katcat1]

My suggestions would be to check out Bobbi Brown and Laura Mercier even Estee Lauder.

[Pook]

@Quinny  I have used Mally's for years and it is not available now.  I have looked everywhere for broncze eyeliner pencil to no avail.  Then with Sephora found UD's dark metallic copper and Makeup Forever's Metallic bronze which both are a bit darker are close even though not the same.

[Grouchomarx]

I live and die by my bronze eyeliner. Mally evercolor in Amber. I just bought two recently so I’m never without, it’s perfection. Goes on so silky and lasts all day. It’s the perfect color too. Not too dark. 

[SilleeMee]

When I wear a bronze liner, it's this one by ColourPop. Waterproof, intense color and stays put once it sets but also smudgeable right after you apply it.

COLOURPOP

"OVER BOARD LINER" Crème Gel Liner - $5.50+sh

[SilleeMee]

Sorry for that HUGE picture...I couldn't make it smaller. 

Also wanted to mention that the ColourPop pencil liners are all retractable type. Stays on the waterline, too.

And if it matters...Kylie Cosmetics is made by the same company who makes ColourPop stuff.

[FlowerBear]

This morning I ordered Skinn liners (smudge sticks) , He says they are waterproof and you get 3 on sale. I think he said they are gel. 

[Quinny]

---

@Brisky wrote:
Have you looked at Bobbie Brown's site?
What is your eye color? Mine is blue and when I put Bronze on they pop big time.

---

Blue eyes for me, too!