Dear BSD: I agree, BM hit the skids when it got sold. Price went up, quality tanked. As did Philosophy, when Coty purchased it. As did QVC itself: the overall quality of QVC took a huge dive after they hired a former WalMart exec as their CEO. Now I rarely purhcase from the Q. I'll read the beauty forums every so often, though.
A cosmetics thought: be cognizant of which corporation owns each brand. There are only a few major cosmetic corporations worldwide. As of 2011: Estée Lauder owns: Aveda, Clinique, Bobbi Brown, MAC, Origins, La Mer, Michael Kors, Ojon. L’Oreal owns: Maybelline,Garnier, Lancôme, Shu Uemura, Kiehl’s, Giorgio Armani, Dermablend, Body Shop, Skinceuticals, Ralph Lauren, Yves Saint Laurent. Procter & Gamble owns: Cover Girl, Max Factor, Olay. Johnson & Johnson owns: Neutrogena, Aveeno, Clean & Clear, RoC. Louis Vuitton-Moet Hennessy (LVMH) owns: Dior, Guerlain, Givenchy, Benefit, Fresh, Make Up For Ever, and Sephora’s namesake line. Shiseido owns: Cle de Peau, NARS, Jean Paul Gaultier. Sorry I haven't updated my list since 2011.
Another cosmetics thought: focus on ingedients, not brand names.
Final cosmetics thought: I, too, fought hyperpigmentation (and redness) for years. Additionally, a major blue vein under each eye, for which I tried every concealer known to man. The older I got, the worse it all became. All I ever wanted was even skin tone and those veins gone. So I researched, saved money for a long time, and found a stellar dermatologist in another state. He specializes in lasers; has 7 different types. He removed my two large veins, and did IPL on my entire face. Best investment I ever made. Now I have the even skin tone I've always wanted. Side effects: Swelled up like a blowfish, coffee ground appearance all over face, took two weeks to go away. Well worth it at the end. I no longer need concealer at all, nor full coverage foundation!!! Plus Husband says I look 10 years younger! After all the money I spent searching for perfect foundation and concealer - wish I had done this years ago. I know now to focus on my skin itself, in lieu of cosmetics.
Best wishes to you.