Beauty

[Blondelle]

On 7/14/2014 JMFINLEY001 said:

I love them!!!! I ordered the Duo last time they were presented and I got the Navy and Smoke and both are gorgeous colors-very saturated and last on me all day. I do use Trish McEvoy's Eye Base, but these last until I cleanse my face at night!!!!I want the Black and Brown colors next!

Are those the pencil ones that you like? I was hoping to get some feedback on the ones in the pot.

[Dorothy11]

I have not used the eyeliner pencils, but do have the liner in the pots - espresso and silky taupe.

First thing to consider:

The pencil duo is .017 oz. x 2 = .034 (three-hundredths of an ounce) for $26.36.

The pot is .12 oz or 3 1/2 times as much product for less - $24.00.

I have hooded eyes and the liner in the pots stays all day. It's a little messy to apply (don't bother with the brush sold here) but works well with a thin brush. I've had them for a couple of months and they are not drying out. The colors are very nice too - will probably get the graphite. Sign up on the IT site and you can get free shipping, no tax and special offers!

[Kjelle]

I am still working with mine, but I find so far they are too soft. I can't get a sharp line and they don't seem to 'set'. I think Jamie mentioned you have a few seconds to correct before they set, but I think it just stays moist, if you know what I mean.

[FUTURE]

I've only used the gel liner in the pots -- LOVE them!!

[skh47]

i tried this eyeliner and it does go on really smoothly and easy, but it bothered my eyes! i used it on the waterline on the top lashes. it felt terrible after it dried down, it just made my eyes feel too heavy and irritated. i returned it and went back to using urban decay. it's not as bold looking but it feels better.

[Bella Carro]

I haven't tried It liners but I have noticed that I really prefer pot liners lately. I feel I get a much better line and have better control. They seem to last better throughout the day, too. I love Nars. For removal, I have found Sephora's blue remover for waterproof eye m/u to be effective, gentle and affordable.

[cuddlesmama]

Do you pot eyeliners for the lower lid or only for the top lid.

[liz ae]

Am wearing IT pencil gel liner now. Put it on at 4 am, it will be there for me at 11 pm. Maybe it stays on for me because I always wear an eye shadow base. It used to come off with my regular cleanser. Now I used a makeup remover but that is because the cleanser has changed.

Not crazy about the sharpener but short of that would reorder.

[GigiDana]

Edited Oops...different product but I wrote all of this so it may benefit someone. A257169 I own three..black, brown and navy and LOVE them all! I line my inner eyelid and it has been the only eyeliner I have used that stays and doesn't make it's way to my tear ducts giving me that black blob. ( if u line the inside of you eyelids, you know what I mean). The brush makes it so easy to apply and blend on the lash line. It is truly waterproof! When I use the brown one, I use a little on my eyebrow and an eyebrow brush and it makes for a great brow definer. I like these pots of eyeliners as I used one by tarte in the past but it dried up pretty fast. I've had my three pots from IT for 6 months and so far so good. When you think about how minuscule amount of product is in a eyeliner stick and look at the amount in the pots, you know this is a great value! The brush is a real bonus too!

[glmama]

I bought a duo of these for the first time during the CEW event. I consider myself a liner aficionado at this point (does it count that I have tried them all and keep buying????), and they are just 'meh' to me. I find them drying (and seem to dry out while unused). I do not notice any "no-tug" properties. In fact, I don't find them that easy to use. I won't buy them again.