Reply
Respected Contributor
Posts: 4,936
Registered: ‎07-02-2015

INFORMATION ABOUT DIFFERENT MAYONNAISE BRANDS

[ Edited ]

This might help answer some questions about which brands are "best" for various tastes and nutritional or health needs:

 

 

Here's the list of mayonnaise brands available in the U.S., along with their gluten-free status:

  • Best Foods/Hellman's Mayonnaise. Best Foods and Hellman's, owned by Unilever, are the same; Hellman's is sold east of the Rocky Mountains, while Best Foods is marketed west of the mountain chain. The company makes a variety of different types of mayo and spreads. Hellman's/Best Food Real Mayonnaise, Light Mayonnaise, Low-Fat Mayonnaise Dressing, Limited Edition Southwestern Ranch Reduced Fat Mayonnaise and Tartar Sauce are marked gluten-free, while other flavors are not. Look for the words "gluten-free" in the ingredients panel to be sure. The company reports that its vinegar is derived from corn.
  • Blue Plate Mayonnaise. This southern regional mayonnaise brand boasts a dedicated following. Blue Plate offers three different versions of mayo: Real Mayonnaise, Light Mayonnaise, and Light Mayonnaise with Olive Oil. It also makes Blue Plate Sandwich Spread, made with relish and mayonnaise. All are marked gluten-free, but they do contain distilled vinegar that can be sourced from gluten grains.
  • Duke's Mayonnaise. This southern regional brand of mayonnaise advertises itself as "the only major mayonnaise on the market that contains no sugar." Dukes (a subsidiary of C.F. Sauer Co.) also considers the mayonnaise gluten-free. Dukes' mayonnaise products contain both cider vinegar and distilled vinegar; a customer service representative reports the distilled vinegar is derived from corn.
  • Hain Mayonnaise. Hain Pure Foods, part of the Hain Celestial Group, makes several different types of mayonnaise from safflower and canola oils. None of them appear on Hain Celestial's gluten-free list or carry the red "GF" triangle symbol used by the company, so steer clear.
  • Heinz Mayonnaise. Heinz lists six mayonnaise products on its U.S. list of products with no gluten ingredients: Mayonnaise, Light Mayonnaise, Deli Mayonnaise-Moroccan, Deli Mayonnaise-Carmelized Onion, Deli Mayonnaise-Roast Garlic, and Deli Mayonnaise-Sun-Dried Tomato. Heinz reports that the distilled vinegar used in its condiments is derived from corn.
  • Hollywood Mayonnaise. This is another brand of mayonnaise from Hain Celestial. Like Hain Pure Foods' mayonnaise products, Hollywood products are not considered gluten-free.
  • Kraft Brand Mayonnaise and Miracle Whip. Kraft markets three different types of Miracle Whip — Original, Light and Fat-Free. The company also makes a dozen or so mayonnaise products, including Real Mayo in full-fat, light and fat-free versions, plus several "Sandwich Shop" flavored mayonnaise products in squeeze bottles. Kraft Foods has a policy of clearly disclosing any gluten-containing ingredients on the label. Therefore, if you don't see any obvious gluten-containing ingredients, the product doesn't contain any. That doesn't mean, however, that it qualifies as "gluten-free" — it still could be subject to gluten cross-contamination in processing. Some particularly sensitive people report problems with Miracle Whip, particularly with the Light and Fat-Free varieties. The vinegar used in Kraft products can be sourced from any grain, including gluten grains, according to a customer service representative.
  • Trader Joe's Mayonnaise. Trader Joe's markets three store-branded types of mayo: Organic, Real and Reduced Fat. All appear on the retailer's "no gluten ingredients" list. Beware, though: T.J.'s products can be subject to gluten cross-contamination at the packaging facility, and some people (especially those who are particularly sensitive to trace gluten) steer clear entirely as a result.
  • Spectrum Mayonnaise. Spectrum Organics markets canola-based and soy-based plain mayonnaise, plus a variety of "artisan" flavored mayonnaise products. All are considered gluten-free by the company, and feature labels with a "gluten-free" designation. Spectrum reports that the vinegar in its mayonnaise products is derived from corn and the gluten grain rye, and states that testing found no gluten in the alcohol used to make that vinegar. Nonetheless, if you're one who reacts to gluten grain-based vinegar, I'd advise some caution with Spectrum mayonnaise products.
  • Vegenaise. Follow Your Heart, a company that produces vegan products, makes Vegenaise in Original, Reduced Fat, Grapeseed Oil, Organic and Soy-Free versions. It also makes a half-dozen flavored Vegenaise spreads. All Vegenaise products are gluten-free, according to the company, which states that the enzymes used to produce the brown rice syrup in the products are considered gluten-free (enzymes used to process brown rice often contain barley). In addition, the vinegar used is apple cider vinegar, according to the company.

 

 

Respected Contributor
Posts: 4,936
Registered: ‎07-02-2015

Re: INFORMATION ABOUT DIFFERENT MAYONNAISE BRANDS

[ Edited ]

Duke's mayonnaise has an interesting history.

 

It has probably become even better known since music star Trisha Yearwood (Garth Brooks' wife) has been featured in the media with her Southern recipes.  She is a fan of Duke's mayo.

 

Here's a Washington Post story that covers the brand's history and "cult status" in the South. 

 

 

http://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/food/dukes-mayonnaise-the-southern-spread-with-a-cult-follow...

Honored Contributor
Posts: 11,423
Registered: ‎03-12-2010

Re: INFORMATION ABOUT DIFFERENT MAYONNAISE BRANDS

I was going to add not to forget Vegenaise, but I see it at the bottom

 

Also, when posting articles such as this, don't forget to include the source.  There are several reasons for this.

[was Homegirl] Love to be home . . . thus the screen name. Joined 2003.
Respected Contributor
Posts: 4,936
Registered: ‎07-02-2015

Re: INFORMATION ABOUT DIFFERENT MAYONNAISE BRANDS

[ Edited ]

I know it's important to name a source, but I keep running into trouble posting today and juggling back and forth between internet sites, using copy/paste functions.  It takes a lot more steps these days to post items here, too, or at least so it seems.

 

At any rate, info about Duke's and any other type of mayo is abundantly available by asking a search engine for "Duke's mayonnaise" or ingredients of brand-name mayonnaise.  The site where I copied that info covers the gluten status of various brands, obviously.  I'll try to find it again, but it's probably quicker if those who want to know do the google search on their own.

 

Edit:  OK, here's the source link:

 

http://celiacdisease.about.com/od/Gluten-Free-Condiments/a/Gluten-free-Mayonnaise.htm

 

I wasn't specifically searching for info about gluten, but that site had the best list of different brands, and it identified Duke's as the brand with no sugar......I guess that's why I like to use Duke's.

Respected Contributor
Posts: 3,056
Registered: ‎01-30-2015

Re: INFORMATION ABOUT DIFFERENT MAYONNAISE BRANDS

Thank you for this info...very interesting!

 

Respected Contributor
Posts: 3,650
Registered: ‎03-13-2010

Re: INFORMATION ABOUT DIFFERENT MAYONNAISE BRANDS

Thanks for the interesting info on mayo.  Just a note for those who are old enough to remember the A & P brand of mayo called "Ann Page"..  My mother always purchased it when we were kids back in the 50s and 60s.. Just curious if anyone else remembers that very tasty mayo.. It was the best! 

Cinderella is proof that a new pair of shoes can change your life!
Honored Contributor
Posts: 22,267
Registered: ‎10-25-2010

Re: INFORMATION ABOUT DIFFERENT MAYONNAISE BRANDS

I remember the A&P Brands....They were only sold at our local ACME Grocery store. My mother purchased many A&P products, not just the mayo