Reply
Respected Contributor
Posts: 4,781
Registered: ‎03-10-2010

I posted a couple days ago (maybe longer) that I bought just the frosting from Cheryl's Cookies and here's my review.

I have stored in the frig, opened one tub up and since it was still chilled, it was thick and pasty. Let it come to room temp and the consistancy was much better but it had "puddles" of something in it...stirred it up and it seemed fine. Let it sit on the counter overnight and looked at it the next morning and there were those "puddles" again...not sure what they are but looking at the ingrediants, all it says is powered sugar, butter, evaporated milk and flavoring. Taste, just OK....would I buy again, probably no.

I'm curious though what those "puddles" are...they are darker than the vanilla frosting but I can't imagine that the vanilla flavoring would seperate, think I'll call and ask.