Which is better

hennypenny · ‎03-10-2010

Cabana girl or Beach Party three in one shower gel? Not sure which to order--

Are they both strictly a fruit flavor?

colliemom4 · ‎09-08-2010

I can't exactly recall what Cabana Girl smells like though I did own it at one time. It smells pleasant but I love Beach Party. It smells very tropical pineappley if that's a word lol.

hennypenny · ‎03-10-2010

Thank you Collie- I wasn't sure which would be more pleasing. I use pure grace but thought something summery might be nice. I normally don't care for ""food fragrances"" but these tropical fruits sound nice for summer.

colliemom4 · ‎09-08-2010

You are very welcome. Please let us know how you like it. I thought more people would answer on this thread. Have a great day!

hennypenny · ‎03-10-2010

I thought so too. Maybe others haven't tried the products. They seemed similar so was curious to see what most people thought. Will wait a bit and then go with your recommendation. Again, thanks Colliemom.

cal-gal · ‎04-20-2010

Hi hennypenny, colliemom3!

I have both of these scents, and they are very different from each other, yet I still enjoy both of them ${#emotions_dlg.thumbup}$

While both are "coconut" mixed scents, Cabana Girl has a wonderful fresh guava scent, versus Beach Party's juicy pineapple scent. If I had to pick which was more 'fruity', I would say that would be Beach Party (the pineapple could be considered 'fruity'). Have you eaten a guava before, or had real guava juice? It's a nice refreshing flavor, and almost has a floral note to the fruit, if that makes sense ... so I would say Cabana Girl is more fresh than fruity. Just my personal opinion Wink but I hope that helps!

Sometimes, I crave using Beach Party, whereas other days I crave the refreshing guava scent of Cabana Girl. All comes down to my mood that day, and what I am craving ${#emotions_dlg.biggrin}$

I hope you like whichever scent you decide to purchase, let us know what you end up selecting (if not both, LOL!).

Have a good evening!

colliemom4 · ‎09-08-2010

Hi cal-gal! Thanks for the great reviews. I could not think of what Cabana Girl smelled like, but now that you mention it I do recall the Guava. I only had one bottle and used it pretty quickly, but I purchased many bottles of Beach Party shower gel and lotion. I love Pineapples so this scent was right up my alley! I realize there are coconut notes in both gels, but I was so concentraed on the pineapple....my fave! Actually, I've used that one up too! Nice seeing your post here!

hennypenny · ‎03-10-2010

I love both guava and pineapple scents, so may splurge and buy both. lol! Will wait til morning and see if I can talk myself into being sensible and frugal...... by the way Kerns guava nectar is heavenly! I don't know if it is available everywhere. Here in Ca it is a juice that comes in a milk carton.