Reply
Respected Contributor
Posts: 2,333
Registered: ‎03-12-2010

What if someone was mad at you and wanted to get back at you by reporting erroneous information regarding something you had done on the road that you had not? The police would be even so much busier than they are now and it would be your word against theirs--it would be out of control

Respected Contributor
Posts: 3,356
Registered: ‎01-03-2012
Called 911 a few times on drunk drivers. You know what a dispatcher told me in CA? The cops needed to see it in order to go after them.
Honored Contributor
Posts: 77,981
Registered: ‎03-10-2010
On 3/22/2014 Q2girl said: Called 911 a few times on drunk drivers. You know what a dispatcher told me in CA? The cops needed to see it in order to go after them.
That's not true; that's why they give field sobriety and breathalyzer tests. They encourage people here to call and report drunk divers and post a phone number on PSA announcements.
New Mexico☀️Land Of Enchantment
Super Contributor
Posts: 2,314
Registered: ‎03-14-2010
On 3/22/2014 Q2girl said: Called 911 a few times on drunk drivers. You know what a dispatcher told me in CA? The cops needed to see it in order to go after them.

It is certainly not true these days in CA....

Super Contributor
Posts: 2,314
Registered: ‎03-14-2010
On 3/22/2014 Ladybug724 said:

What if someone was mad at you and wanted to get back at you by reporting erroneous information regarding something you had done on the road that you had not? The police would be even so much busier than they are now and it would be your word against theirs--it would be out of control


the reporting of any unwitnessed crime is your word against someone's, should we all stop reporting things that happen to us? based on the far fetched notion that people who have vendettas will misuse their "power"?

So if you are the victim of a hit and run, don't bother writing down the persons license #- its your word against theirs?

And guess what? reporting crime that didn't really happen, IS a crime! and you can go to jail for doing so- This is one of the things that keeps those wacky folks that might be "mad at you" from acting in such a way!

Super Contributor
Posts: 319
Registered: ‎06-28-2010

Yes, a District Attorney has the responsibility for prosecuting criminal cases in the district where he or she was either elected or appointed to represent and bad driving would be a criminal prosecution. Your friend would either pay the fine and accept responsibility or she could have her day in court. In more serious cases the district attorney or one of his assistants would present the case to a grand jury where your peers would decide if there was enough evidence to press charges. In lesser offenses, the DA may indeed decide (as one of his official duties) to file charges. He could later, if for instance someone died days later, to present the case to the Grand Jury. The DA does not have the right to find someone guilty that is the Judge and or jury. When the policeman came to the door your friend could have said I was not the driver, I loaned my car to "so and so".

My son one time called 911 to report a car driving recklessly on the interstate. He gave a description of the car and the direction they were driving. Later a state patrol officer called and told him that they had indeed pulled the car over for driving recklessly and the driver was drunk. The officer told him that he probably saved some lives that night as they stopped him before an accident.

Individuals who own a vehicle have a responsibility and duty to ensure that they drive in a safe and appropriate manner. When a person drives carelessly, he or she operates a vehicle or streetcar without the proper attention or a reasonable consideration for other people on the road. A careless driving charge has to do with a citation that implies that the person isn't drivingtheir vehicle in a prudent manner.

There are several examples of behavior that could warrant a careless driving charge. Driving through a red light could be considered careless driving, as can driving inappropriately close to another vehicle. Even a person's conduct while they are driving could be considered careless. For example, an individual who is reading a map, looking at another passenger, or tuning a car radio while the vehicle is moving could be in danger of being charged with careless driving. Careless driving laws vary depending upon jurisdiction. The fine could range from a few hundred dollars to over a $1000 US Dollars. Another potential consequence of a person who drives carelessly is the possibility that his or her insurance could increase. Insurance companies routinely monitor an individual’s driving record to determine their premiums. A careless driver could see their insurance increase up to 100%. In some cases, an insurance company may choose to cancel a person's policy.

If you see someone driving recklessly: "What would you do?" Just ignore the situation or would you step forward and call the authorities? I do not believe that we should personally intervene in the situation, but I do believe we all have a responsibility to try and keep an accident from happening.

Respected Contributor
Posts: 3,071
Registered: ‎03-14-2010

Maybe the police officer witnessed the careless driving himself while off duty in his private vehicle and maybe with his family present. He couldn't do anything about it at the time it happened, but wrote down the license number and followed up himself. It must have been a serious offense if the police can take the time to go to a house and report the incident. A lot of municipalities don't have the manpower to do that.

Respected Contributor
Posts: 3,958
Registered: ‎09-28-2010
On 3/22/2014 judgejudith said:

Yes, a District Attorney has the responsibility for prosecuting criminal cases in the district where he or she was either elected or appointed to represent and bad driving would be a criminal prosecution. Your friend would either pay the fine and accept responsibility or she could have her day in court. In more serious cases the district attorney or one of his assistants would present the case to a grand jury where your peers would decide if there was enough evidence to press charges. In lesser offenses, the DA may indeed decide (as one of his official duties) to file charges. He could later, if for instance someone died days later, to present the case to the Grand Jury. The DA does not have the right to find someone guilty that is the Judge and or jury. When the policeman came to the door your friend could have said I was not the driver, I loaned my car to "so and so".

My son one time called 911 to report a car driving recklessly on the interstate. He gave a description of the car and the direction they were driving. Later a state patrol officer called and told him that they had indeed pulled the car over for driving recklessly and the driver was drunk. The officer told him that he probably saved some lives that night as they stopped him before an accident.

If you see someone driving recklessly: "What would you do?" Just ignore the situation or would you step forward and call the authorities? I do not believe that we should personally intervene in the situation, but I do believe we all have a responsibility to try and keep an accident from happening.

You can certainly call and report dangerous situations. In most cases, the police attempt to locate the person ON THE HIGHWAY, and intercede before a deadly situation arises. If someone is reported as potentially driving drunk, the evidence of the impairment can be obtained even if the officer did not see the occurrence.

It's conceivable that more than one person called the police and reported the license plate. Still, unless someone saw the driver clear enough to be able to identify them in a line-up, there would be no way to prove that the car owner was the driver and that is why I have a problem believing the officer showing up at the home was not normal procedure.

Respected Contributor
Posts: 3,958
Registered: ‎09-28-2010
On 3/22/2014 stilltamn8r said:
On 3/22/2014 Ladybug724 said:

What if someone was mad at you and wanted to get back at you by reporting erroneous information regarding something you had done on the road that you had not? The police would be even so much busier than they are now and it would be your word against theirs--it would be out of control


the reporting of any unwitnessed crime is your word against someone's, should we all stop reporting things that happen to us? based on the far fetched notion that people who have vendettas will misuse their "power"?

So if you are the victim of a hit and run, don't bother writing down the persons license #- its your word against theirs?

And guess what? reporting crime that didn't really happen, IS a crime! and you can go to jail for doing so- This is one of the things that keeps those wacky folks that might be "mad at you" from acting in such a way!

You are still providing situations where there would be evidence vs a situation where there is nothing but someone's claim.

There are plenty of heinous crimes that are committed, rape being one of them, that unless there is concrete evidence of the crime, the offender walks. It takes more than your word vs someone elses.

Respected Contributor
Posts: 2,333
Registered: ‎03-12-2010
On 3/22/2014 stilltamn8r said:
On 3/22/2014 Ladybug724 said:

What if someone was mad at you and wanted to get back at you by reporting erroneous information regarding something you had done on the road that you had not? The police would be even so much busier than they are now and it would be your word against theirs--it would be out of control


the reporting of any unwitnessed crime is your word against someone's, should we all stop reporting things that happen to us? based on the far fetched notion that people who have vendettas will misuse their "power"?

So if you are the victim of a hit and run, don't bother writing down the persons license #- its your word against theirs?

And guess what? reporting crime that didn't really happen, IS a crime! and you can go to jail for doing so- This is one of the things that keeps those wacky folks that might be "mad at you" from acting in such a way!

A hit-and-run can be proven. And yes I do believe there would be too much abuse--that isn't far-fetched, people abuse stuff all the time