MOFirmer - I mainly use only the seasonals (with Wen Men, PJP, BGT, 319 and MIF thrown in). I have thick, wavy hair that tends to be frizzy when I use the hair dryer and don't smooth it with something. If I air dry, I have lovely waves, but it takes half the day to air dry, LOL.
My texture is probably more fine than coarse, although I have 5 to 6 different hair types on my head and plenty of cowlicks. It's also color treated - I get highlights about 3 times a year.
Of the classics, I always liked Tea Tree and the Lavender. I know that many have said that Lavender is drying for them, but I never had that issue.
I think those that gave advice regarding POM being a good option, I would agree if you like the seasonals that POM would be close in formula. I have a hard time getting past the scent of POM because I find it too fruity. Honestly, for me, I don't notice that much of a difference in performance between all the formulas, so I just go by the scents that I like. It may be because I cleanse every day that I don't notice much difference. I alternate between 3 formulas a season - every day is a different formula. For spring, I have the Lilac, Peony and Cherry Blossom in the rotation, with a Gardenia waiting in the wings. I also add some 319 to pump up the formula if the consistency seems on the thin side.
If you can get some 16 oz sizes, then you could try them out. If there are some you don't care for, you can mix them with ones that you like to use them up.