Le Creuset DOES sell "second choice" or "seconds".....the sticker on the pot is orange in color, and the box has a vivid green sticker on it indicating seconds.
You can easily see examples of this on Ebay by looking up "Le Creuset Second Choix" or "Seconds"...even under the regular listing, seconds are clearly marked. And they include pictures of the boxes with the green stickers on them.
QVC would have to get all new NEW item boxes, switch them out, and that would be a heck of a deceit. Hard to keep a secret that large with all the people that handle the product at Q...all the hosts, vendors, set up people...just sounds crazy.
I do think they sell runs of colors that DON'T sell well....on LC's website, the NEW colors are out, and they are not any that Q is currently selling as the TSV.
Thier cooking ability is not changed by the color.
They DID sell the Classic line for the longest time, but today's TSV looks like the Signature line with the larger loop handles. It's a nice offering...one I don't need, but nice....
That saucepot they are selling with the phenolic handle ...that handle has poor reviews for the material it's made from. The LC site has a really good price on an entire cast iron 2+ qt saucepan which I think is a better value, and it comes in a million colors...
Look on Ebay at seconds to see what I mean.
I've ordered lots of LC from Q, Ebay ( new) and Le Creuset and have never had a problem with any of the stuff I got..
I DO recall a lot of complaints about that lidded roaster being packed with no packing between the cast iron lid and the roaster...that sure sounds bad. The ones I've all bought have been really well packed....
A salesman in the LC outlet is just that..a salesman trying to make a sale. Doesn't surprise me that they may have implied what is sold on Q are "seconds"....they want your money!!!
And it's odd because the LC outlets also sell seconds in clearly marked boxes....and that's NOT what you get from QVC.
Q sells a lot of stuff I think is not worth the money, but I don't think they would try to pass off seconds of LC as new.
No need to. People buy it all the time almost to sell out when it's shown on TV.
Could there be defective pieces? Sure . But I don't think they deliberately lie about what they're selling.
And I guess the DON'T actually specify the LC they're selling is first quality, but they don't do that on any of the other stuff they sell either....1000's of items.