Shoes

[manny2]

Both are nice, but I am a platform girl. I would go with the first one.

[kze]

I like both but #2 is my favorite. 

[Queen of shop]

#2

[NYCLatinaMe]

---

@Another new name Sue wrote:

My thoughts--I think they are both ok.  The first one has  more support for your forefoot which is nice and more toe coverage, but the heel on the other one is more attractive.  The first one will make you a little taller because othe heel looks a tiny bit taller, and the sole under the ball of the food is higher.  For that reason you might not feel the height of the heel as much, so the first one could be more comfortable.  Color on both are nice.  

Are they here on the Q?

---

They are both Naturalizer.  The first one is on the Q in a different color (A608289), but I didn't see it in my size.  Now I do.  While looking around for my size, I found the nude, which I like better.  And then I found 2.  It's called Vera.

[magicmoodz]

@NYCLatinaMe 

And here I thought your shoe wardrobe was complete. As a fellow shoe lover there is no such thing😂

I agree with @amyb. It really depends on how you plan to incorporate these shoes into your wardrobe. The first pair is definitely trending. It offers more stability with the chunky heel and a bit more coverage if that is necessary or more appropriate in your workplace. I see the second pair as more delicate and a bit dressier. 

I really do like them both. Such a dilemma. So you know what I am going to say. Buy them both, justifying that you will have a pair and a spare!👠👠

[Goldengate8361]

I like them both, but I'd definitely choose #1. The first one  looks much more comfortable to wear. The platform really helps in how they feel "on." 

[moonandthestars]

@NYCLatinaMe I'm a big fan of nude colored shoes.  Without knowing what you look like or what you are going to wear the shoes with, if I had to choose (for me), I would probably choose #1.  I like the platform, I'm a fan of a little clunkiness in shoes - and I mean that in the best way.  I think it adds some quirkiness and balance to the outfit and the leg.  A little more grounding.  Both shoes are great tho.  If it were me, I'd want to try them on and see which looks and feels best in person.

[GenXmuse]

They're both really cute! For me, I like number one because it's chunkier and would be more stable for me to wear but they look more casual. If it's a dressier special occasion, I might do number one. My feet are wide too and delicate shoes are hard for me to find and wear. 

[NYCLatinaMe]

---

@moonandthestars wrote:

@NYCLatinaMe I'm a big fan of nude colored shoes.  Without knowing what you look like or what you are going to wear the shoes with, if I had to choose (for me), I would probably choose #1.  I like the platform, I'm a fan of a little clunkiness in shoes - and I mean that in the best way.  I think it adds some quirkiness and balance to the outfit and the leg.  A little more grounding.  Both shoes are great tho.  If it were me, I'd want to try them on and see which looks and feels best in person.

---

@moonandthestars I so agree, I wish they were here and I could try them on.  Tired of shopping and returning when things don't work out.

The shoe in blue is just gorgeous and that is what drew me in.  A608289

But as I wrote, they initially didn't have my size so I poked around.  The shoe is $140 and the blue wouldn't get that much use, I like and wear "nude" shoes a lot, so when I saw that, thought better value.  And I had thought the platform would make it comfortable, but the nude doesn't look as comfortable as the blue suede.  Love suede!  Love the blue shade!  The nude look like the shoe would be hard and clunky, and sometimes platforms are hard to walk in.  Naturalizer shoes are not cushy. No cushiness mentioned in the description.

And with "2", sometimes thin soles with heels are not sturdy, sometimes the shoes feel like they splay at the heel.  And the strap over the toe is thinner than I would like, could they dig at my toes, or show off the "bad" part of my toes.

I do stand and walk around in my shoes.  I don't do much sitting when I go out.

Anyway, my naturalizer store, where I was a regular closed off years ago, but you made me look, and it looks like they opened a new store in 2019.  Did not know that, since I became a shut in during the pandemic.

So maybe I'll go see if they have them.

[rockygems123]

@NYCLatinaMeThis was my nude shoe of choice, also purchased black suede. Happy with the quality and comfort. Your choices look beautiful too I like #2.