Both are great. The styles are different IMO. Kate Spade has more variety and price points. Kate Space can be conservative, and whimsical. Tory Burch is a little more consevative IMO. Both are equally well made, and luxurious. I own about 5 Tory Burch, and about 8 Kate Spade.But I have bought a few for my GD's over the years. I have leather, and straw bags from each line. Kate Spade has better sales for sure. But Kate Spade also designs for her outlet, her regular line and for Saturday... which a medium price point. The quality is always there, but better in her main line. Tory Burch has one line, lousy sales, and has a lot of sell outs! Both designer spoil you rotton with their impeccible delivery. You feel your purchase means something to them, and you mean something to them as a customer. The tissue, the boxes, the high quality bags they use to wrap your purchase. Tory Burch even has a fancy sealed envelope to contain your bill. Hahah, they don't want you to see it right away that's what, LOL!
Kahootz
If you have a pictue of each bag, we could probably enable you, I mean HELP you! I think you will be happy with either purchase. Kate spade has special sales if you sign up for emails. I have gotton a 450.00 handbag for 102 with Tax!
Also, both designers use mrrebates, so I get a big rebate from these two designers. Tory Burch has had 10% rebate at times, that is a nice chunk of change you get back, (concidering the price of her bags).
I have bought my granddaughter several TB bags for special landmarks in their life. . Two are crossbody bags and she has had them for 4-5 years, and went through college with them. So they had to wear like iron, she still wears them. I bought her the TB that has the chain strap, and the big gold, TB metal logo on the front for graduation from college. She loves it, but it is really heavy. The strap weighs it down. Take that into concideration f you are concidering one of her "status" bags. The metal is heavy. The leather and the stitching are wonderful!
Also, be careful with some TB crossbody bags. Some of the straps are NOT adjustable, and were too long for my GD, and too short for me.
HTH
“sometimes you have to bite your upper lip and put sunglasses on”….Bob Dylan