So happy Ava is doing well on it. I agree with you ... as long as they do well on it and like it, the price doesn't matter so much ... especially if it keeps them from having to go to the vet.
I haven't tried The Farmer's Dog, but recently started giving my dogs Freshpet on top of their kibble. I had always figured Freshpet must not be very good since Walmart and grocery stores sell it ... but Dog Food Advisor gave it high marks, so I decided to try it.
My mastiff has been on prescription Royal Canin Hydrolyzed Protein kibble and canned food since I adopted him last year. I've tried many different commercial kibble and canned foods ... grain/no grain and different proteins ... his system couldn't handle any of it. I wanted to try something new for my American Hairless Terriers since they seemed to be getting bored with their canned food, so I decided to try Freshpet sprinkled over their kibble. They (and my GSD, Boston and Bloodhound) loved it. After a week or so, the mastiff started whining at meal time because he wanted some, so I finally gave in and let him try a little. He loved it and he didn't have any bad side-affects from it, so now he gets it, too. Now I'm really confused ... he's doing fine on the chicken Freshpet, but couldn't handle any of the commercial chicken kibble/canned foods I gave him. I'm just happy he can eat something that's not a prescription food that I can get in a local store ... especially with all of the current supply/shipping issues. Now ... if I could just find a commercial kibble he could eat that doesn't bother his system.