Reply
Honored Contributor
Posts: 17,562
Registered: ‎10-25-2010

Re: Pension Fund in Critical Status -- OH NO!!!


@ccassaday wrote:

@Carmie wrote:

@ccassaday wrote:

@151949 wrote:

This happened about 30 years ago(pre IRA) so take that into consideration - my DH's company was sold and along with it , the pension fund. The new company did not currently have a pension plan nor did they want to get involved with one  so they returned to each employee exactly what he had deposited in his fund. None of the money that the company had put in - no interest or earning it had accrued etc. They kept all that, all the employees got was reimbursed their contribution. So , at 43 years old my DH had to start all over from scratch to save for his retirement.


Even with a pension you need to get some mutual funds and open something like a 401k if your employer doesn’t offer it.


You can lose big time money placed in 401k's  too.  I lost six figures TWICE in my 401k throughout my working career.

 

They are not always as safe as they may seem.  Anytime you invest where there is potential to make money on your investments, there is a risk.

 

You will make next to nothing in no risk accounts.


Of course you can. Especislly if you arent diversified. But over the long run you will have so much money.  If you have 600k and lose 50k you will make that up. Plus if you are diversified the amount you lose from one stock will probably minimal by the. gain of another. As you get close to retirement its probably smart to rearrange your portfolio. Diversify diversify diversify.


You are young and you are inexperienced.  You are going by what your parents did or you looked at someone's experience and came  to a conclusion, but unless you personally lived it...you have no first hand knowledge. What you are saying is common knowledge and is in every brochure handed out by investment companies.

 

I lost over half of my money twice in my 401k. The market was much different than it is now.  The first time, I recovered.  The second time I did not.  I would have been thrilled to only lose 50k.  

 

Yes, I invested in other areas and I was diversified, so I wasn't broke 100%, but can tell you that it hurts to lose so much money in a period of a few days.  I lost a couple Hundred thousand of dollars and it is gone, gone, gone.

 

I am wondering how you will make out when you are old and your parents are gone. It probably won't be easy.  The future is uncertain.  What worked yesterday, might not work tomorrow.

 

I know many people who were set up for their old age and things didn't go as planned.  One couple was investing their money heavily for their future and most of their investments were stolen.  

 

The wife is eligible for SS, the husband is not. He never paid into SS with his job and he had to work after retirement for 25 years more somewhere else. Her company went bankrupt and she got no pension.  Her employer was skimming the money he was supposed to be putting into a 401k for years.  The employees tried to get their money back, but it was gone.  He went to jail, but what good was that?

 

The husband is eligible for SS now, but SS deducts the amount he is receiving from his employee pension each month, so he doesn't receive too much, but every bit helps.

 

My own sister lost her pension...company went bankrupt and she lost her deceased husband's pension when she became  eligible for SS.  She had a nice nest egg and inherited some money, but she got old and sick and her home needed repairs, etc.

 

Long story short, she ran out of money and she ain't dead yet. Currently, I am helping to support her and another family member who is old and sick too. She has been on disability SS since she was in her 50's.  She is in her 80's now.

 

SS Is not enough live off of and many people, will outlive their savings and investments. SS used to give out money like crazy, but they have cut back on eligibility and I fear it will get worse.

 

Sadly, You can no longer invest your money and live off of the interest like people used. to do.

 

 

 

Esteemed Contributor
Posts: 7,328
Registered: ‎03-09-2010

Re: Pension Fund in Critical Status -- OH NO!!!

It also depends on whether the mutual funds offered in your 401(k) are decent or crappy.
Honored Contributor
Posts: 10,782
Registered: ‎03-10-2010

Re: Pension Fund in Critical Status -- OH NO!!!

I know of 2 older people who had pension funds go broke.  If they are mismanaged, or just go bust, you cant bleed a turnip.  You can try, but it wont yeild the money you lost.  One was with the railroad here in california. Icant remember exactly what happened, but I do know his wife had to run a daycare at 75 to make ends meet.

Honored Contributor
Posts: 8,969
Registered: ‎03-09-2010

Re: Pension Fund in Critical Status -- OH NO!!!


@Carmie wrote:

@ccassaday wrote:

@Carmie wrote:

@ccassaday wrote:

@151949 wrote:

This happened about 30 years ago(pre IRA) so take that into consideration - my DH's company was sold and along with it , the pension fund. The new company did not currently have a pension plan nor did they want to get involved with one  so they returned to each employee exactly what he had deposited in his fund. None of the money that the company had put in - no interest or earning it had accrued etc. They kept all that, all the employees got was reimbursed their contribution. So , at 43 years old my DH had to start all over from scratch to save for his retirement.


Even with a pension you need to get some mutual funds and open something like a 401k if your employer doesn’t offer it.


You can lose big time money placed in 401k's  too.  I lost six figures TWICE in my 401k throughout my working career.

 

They are not always as safe as they may seem.  Anytime you invest where there is potential to make money on your investments, there is a risk.

 

You will make next to nothing in no risk accounts.


Of course you can. Especislly if you arent diversified. But over the long run you will have so much money.  If you have 600k and lose 50k you will make that up. Plus if you are diversified the amount you lose from one stock will probably minimal by the. gain of another. As you get close to retirement its probably smart to rearrange your portfolio. Diversify diversify diversify.


You are young and you are inexperienced.  You are going by what your parents did or you looked at someone's experience and came  to a conclusion, but unless you personally lived it...you have no first hand knowledge. What you are saying is common knowledge and is in every brochure handed out by investment companies.

 

I lost over half of my money twice in my 401k. The market was much different than it is now.  The first time, I recovered.  The second time I did not.  I would have been thrilled to only lose 50k.  

 

Yes, I invested in other areas and I was diversified, so I wasn't broke 100%, but can tell you that it hurts to lose so much money in a period of a few days.  I lost a couple Hundred thousand of dollars and it is gone, gone, gone.

 

I am wondering how you will make out when you are old and your parents are gone. It probably won't be easy.  The future is uncertain.  What worked yesterday, might not work tomorrow.

 

I know many people who were set up for their old age and things didn't go as planned.  One couple was investing their money heavily for their future and most of their investments were stolen.  

 

The wife is eligible for SS, the husband is not. He never paid into SS with his job and he had to work after retirement for 25 years more somewhere else. Her company went bankrupt and she got no pension.  Her employer was skimming the money he was supposed to be putting into a 401k for years.  The employees tried to get their money back, but it was gone.  He went to jail, but what good was that?

 

The husband is eligible for SS now, but SS deducts the amount he is receiving from his employee pension each month, so he doesn't receive too much, but every bit helps.

 

My own sister lost her pension...company went bankrupt and she lost her deceased husband's pension when she became  eligible for SS.  She had a nice nest egg and inherited some money, but she got old and sick and her home needed repairs, etc.

 

Long story short, she ran out of money and she ain't dead yet. Currently, I am helping to support her and another family member who is old and sick too. She has been on disability SS since she was in her 50's.  She is in her 80's now.

 

SS Is not enough live off of and many people, will outlive their savings and investments. SS used to give out money like crazy, but they have cut back on eligibility and I fear it will get worse.

 

Sadly, You can no longer invest your money and live off of the interest like people used. to do.

 

 

 


When the market went south the last time my husbands 401K lost every single employer matched $ and it never recovered.  After a year or so, he made the decision to get out, pulled it in a lump sum and rolled it over into his IRA.

Respected Contributor
Posts: 3,327
Registered: ‎05-09-2016

Re: Pension Fund in Critical Status -- OH NO!!!

[ Edited ]

@ccassaday wrote:

Oh and i wasnt talking not losing any money. Stocks go up and down. But you wont lose a entire portfolio if you are divrrsified and ride it over the long run. 


Please stop giving out investment advice to people that you don't know that is based only on your narrow frame of reference. Everyone's situation is different. Unless you are registered with the SEC as an advisor, what you are doing (telling people to buy mutual funds, open IRA's, etc) is illegal. That's why I specifically suggested that the OP talk to a professional. Although I acutally worked at the management level in institutional investing, I'm no longer doing so and therefore can not legally provide ANY type of advice other than the most general types of things that anyone else could find for themselves. I would never, ever, ever tell someone what type of investment vehicles they should use. 

~The more someone needs to brag about how wonderful, special, successful, wealthy or important they are, the greater the likelihood that it isn't true. ~

Honored Contributor
Posts: 35,290
Registered: ‎08-19-2010

Re: Pension Fund in Critical Status -- OH NO!!!

Woman Surprised

Honored Contributor
Posts: 17,562
Registered: ‎10-25-2010

Re: Pension Fund in Critical Status -- OH NO!!!

@CelticCrafter I did the same thing as your husband did and pulled my money out and reinvested it.

Honored Contributor
Posts: 9,292
Registered: ‎06-10-2015

Re: Pension Fund in Critical Status -- OH NO!!!

Watch out for the re-investing.  When I rolled my 401k over into investments they were doing well.  Then 9/11 happened and the stock market crash and I lost everything, a very sizable retirement.  I was devastated and cried for weeks.  Took me years to get over the loss.  So all my work of 45 plus years went up in smoke.  I would sooner bury my money in a coffee can in my back yard.

Saving time & trouble. If I offend you, I am sorry.
Respected Contributor
Posts: 2,720
Registered: ‎03-11-2010

Re: Pension Fund in Critical Status -- OH NO!!!

[ Edited ]

I know several of my co-workers got devastated by market losses over the years but they had time to get much of it back. A few friends who’d recently retired at the time the markets went down though were worse off. Some of them really lost and actually wound up having to go back to work at least part time. ☹️

Honored Contributor
Posts: 33,580
Registered: ‎03-10-2010

Re: Pension Fund in Critical Status -- OH NO!!!

Our firm once handled an estate where the decedent worked for a company and at the time of his passing, he was getting a pension from the company.  While we were administering the estate, the monthly pension checks stopped and eventually the executor got a letter that the pension fund went belly-up and there would be no more checks.