Reply
Respected Contributor
Posts: 3,784
Registered: ‎03-14-2010

Re: proactiv + vs old proactiv system

On 3/16/2015 clangle said:

One word-CLARISONIC. Combined with the Proactiv (original formula, have not tried the new stuff), works amazing! I too am in my 40's and always had a few pimples, and sometimes a jawline cyst or two, until I began using the Clarisonic. I have been using it for about 6 months now and my skin is CLEAR. Good luck!


I truly am glad Clarisonic works for some people. It didn't work for me. I have very sensitive skin and it broke me out. I used the softest brush with it. I also have very pink skin naturally and it cased me to have broken capillaries. Just another point of view.

Highlighted
Honored Contributor
Posts: 17,491
Registered: ‎03-10-2010

Re: proactiv + vs old proactiv system

I had very painful cystic acne, especially painful along my jaw line. My derm prescribed minocycline (sp?) to clear up the bacteria and a tri-phasal BCP.

Using Retin A helped get rid of the scars.

I use the original Proactive moisturizer, which has been sold out for a while, so I'm thinking they no longer make it.

I have 4 bottles left. After that I will have to find something new. I really like this stuff. It is the only thing I've tried over the years that doesn't break me out.

===================================
QVC Shopper - 1993

# IAMTEAMWEN
Super Contributor
Posts: 487
Registered: ‎03-10-2010

Re: proactiv + vs old proactiv system

My daughter and i have used both formulas and I don't think they are particularly wonderful. specifically I do not think it helps with hormonal acne. I think they are good products and worth trying but definitely not the miracle they are advertised to be. I have had better luck with exfoliation and vitamin C along with Retin A a couple times a week.
Occasional Contributor
Posts: 18
Registered: ‎03-16-2015

Re: proactiv + vs old proactiv system

Old Proactiv is better in my opinion, but I believe they are phasing it out. When it comes to acne, no one product works for everyone. I think the reason the old Proactiv work so much better for me was because of the toner. The toner had glycolic acid in it and the new system does not. I am using Paula's choice products now and getting good results. Just an FYI...QVC prices for Proactiv are ridiculously overpriced. If you want to try it, check out their kiosks in the mall. It's less expensive there.

Regular Contributor
Posts: 224
Registered: ‎07-18-2011

Re: proactiv + vs old proactiv system

Proactiv never worked for my teenage daughter. Now she washes with antibacterial soap and uses spot treatments of tretinoin cream, and her skin is clear. I wasted a fortune on Proactiv.
Occasional Contributor
Posts: 11
Registered: ‎02-12-2014

Re: proactiv + vs old proactiv system

On 3/17/2015 sunny66 said:

Old Proactiv is better in my opinion, but I believe they are phasing it out. When it comes to acne, no one product works for everyone. I think the reason the old Proactiv work so much better for me was because of the toner. The toner had glycolic acid in it and the new system does not. I am using Paula's choice products now and getting good results. Just an FYI...QVC prices for Proactiv are ridiculously overpriced. If you want to try it, check out their kiosks in the mall. It's less expensive there.

Smile I just started the Proactiv + about a week ago. I didn't get the toner in my first kit; I loved that toner from the original Proactiv. But, in the box that I received last week there is a listing of products I can order to compliment the 3-step system, and the Re-texturizing toner is one of them. "It is alcohol free, contains glycolic acid and portulaca extract to help resurface the skin, promote healthy skin turnover, and even the appearance of skin tone." Also apparently comes with their 'specially weaved pads' that you apply it with.

So far, this system compared to the original has really mostly caused extreme peeling and flaking. I preferred the original -- also, the jumbo sizes I could order from here would last me a over a year, as I only used them once a day. In fact I would have the repairing lotion until it expired and have to throw some away, it worked sooo well.{#emotions_dlg.biggrin} It was an auto-delivery for every four months, I would have had to bathe in it to use that much! Edit: I think every four months, iirc.

Super Contributor
Posts: 269
Registered: ‎03-10-2010

Re: proactiv + vs old proactiv system

I used the ""old"" Proactiv with great results and especially loved the glycolic toner as it really evened out the skin tone. Haven't tried the ""new"" Proactiv.

Occasional Contributor
Posts: 18
Registered: ‎03-16-2015

Re: proactiv + vs old proactiv system

On 3/17/2015 azimuth68 said:
On 3/17/2015 sunny66 said:

Old Proactiv is better in my opinion, but I believe they are phasing it out. When it comes to acne, no one product works for everyone. I think the reason the old Proactiv work so much better for me was because of the toner. The toner had glycolic acid in it and the new system does not. I am using Paula's choice products now and getting good results. Just an FYI...QVC prices for Proactiv are ridiculously overpriced. If you want to try it, check out their kiosks in the mall. It's less expensive there.

Smile I just started the Proactiv + about a week ago. I didn't get the toner in my first kit; I loved that toner from the original Proactiv. But, in the box that I received last week there is a listing of products I can order to compliment the 3-step system, and the Re-texturizing toner is one of them. "It is alcohol free, contains glycolic acid and portulaca extract to help resurface the skin, promote healthy skin turnover, and even the appearance of skin tone." Also apparently comes with their 'specially weaved pads' that you apply it with.

So far, this system compared to the original has really mostly caused extreme peeling and flaking. I preferred the original -- also, the jumbo sizes I could order from here would last me a over a year, as I only used them once a day. In fact I would have the repairing lotion until it expired and have to throw some away, it worked sooo well.{#emotions_dlg.biggrin} It was an auto-delivery for every four months, I would have had to bathe in it to use that much! Edit: I think every four months, iirc.

Hi there! {#emotions_dlg.biggrin} I did try the new toner and unfortunately it is no where near as good as the old toner. It is mostly witch hazel and very little glycolic acid. I did like the new proactiv at first, but then I realized it just wasn't as good.

Regular Contributor
Posts: 228
Registered: ‎03-19-2010

Re: proactiv + vs old proactiv system

Thank you all. I ended up ordering the new proactiv plus system. I am going to try use this system until I finish the bottles--I have nothing to loose at this point. I really was having a hard time deciding which system to get though!!