Thanks @Janey2 I was on the wrong YSL site. So I did read the reviews. The rating was 3.3 but 7 out of 7 reviewers recommended it 100%. So I read. First...

The US wants the EU blush colors! (1 star)
We need the rest of the shades (2 stars)
Give us all shades (1 star)
NO. They need to make the compact with blush brush included (1 star)
love the formula disappointing shade ranges (1 star)
So as you can see, all the low ratings were because the US didn't get the colors that the EU got. I had the same complaint and had to get my color from France. If you add up the numbers on the graph and divide, it comes to 4.3 stars
I tried to cancel my Sephora order of Restless Rose but it's too late so I'll have to return it.