Reply
Respected Contributor
Posts: 2,639
Registered: ‎03-11-2010

When You Buy Boxed Hair Color Do You Buy 2 Shades Lighter?

Recently Ihave been reading that when you buy boxed haircolor  you should go 2 shades lighter than what the box says so you hair won't comeout too dark.

Do you think this is true? I have never done that I have been always buying the same color Natural Instincts #20 brown and this time it came out so dark. I don't know if the formula changed or what. Now I finally have it gone and now I am considering just going to a salon to  see what color they would use.. Which I have never done. Do  you thaink salon color looks better than boxed color? Thanks

Respected Contributor
Posts: 3,846
Registered: ‎04-23-2010

Re: When You Buy Boxed Hair Color Do You Buy 2 Shades Lighter?


@cuddlesmama wrote:

Recently Ihave been reading that when you buy boxed haircolor  you should go 2 shades lighter than what the box says so you hair won't comeout too dark.

Do you think this is true? I have never done that I have been always buying the same color Natural Instincts #20 brown and this time it came out so dark. I don't know if the formula changed or what. Now I finally have it gone and now I am considering just going to a salon to  see what color they would use.. Which I have never done. Do  you thaink salon color looks better than boxed color? Thanks


Yes, without a doubt.

“The soul is healed by being with children.”
— Fyodor Dostoyevsky
Respected Contributor
Posts: 2,639
Registered: ‎03-11-2010

Re: When You Buy Boxed Hair Color Do You Buy 2 Shades Lighter?


@mom2four0418 wrote:

@cuddlesmama wrote:

Recently Ihave been reading that when you buy boxed haircolor  you should go 2 shades lighter than what the box says so you hair won't comeout too dark.

Do you think this is true? I have never done that I have been always buying the same color Natural Instincts #20 brown and this time it came out so dark. I don't know if the formula changed or what. Now I finally have it gone and now I am considering just going to a salon to  see what color they would use.. Which I have never done. Do  you thaink salon color looks better than boxed color? Thanks


Yes, without a doubt.


         Thank you.

Respected Contributor
Posts: 3,338
Registered: ‎03-11-2010

Re: When You Buy Boxed Hair Color Do You Buy 2 Shades Lighter?

I've been using Clairol Nice n Easy for years. Using a light blonde. They did change the "numbers" and maybe the formulas a couple years ago, But I was able to find the one most like this:

 

TheBelleOfTheBall.jpg.png

Honored Contributor
Posts: 8,588
Registered: ‎03-14-2010

Re: When You Buy Boxed Hair Color Do You Buy 2 Shades Lighter?

I have never dyed my hair. But I am just mentioning this because most of my friends have their hair dyed at a salon or do it themselves.

 

A friend who dyes her own hair, was having trouble with the color. She called the company's phone number listed on the box of hair dye. She said the person was so helpful. And what she ended up doing was buying 2 different shades of dye to get the color she wanted. She was so pleased with the the help she received.

 

Also, I often hear about highlights and lowlights. And especially since it is summer. Maybe your hair is a bit lighter from being in the sun and that is why the hair dye looks darker?

Honored Contributor
Posts: 18,449
Registered: ‎03-09-2010

Re: When You Buy Boxed Hair Color Do You Buy 2 Shades Lighter?

I used boxed color for a short while in my life, I could never find the same color and it never looked the same

Stop being afraid of what could go wrong and start being positive what could go right.
Honored Contributor
Posts: 18,512
Registered: ‎03-13-2010

Re: When You Buy Boxed Hair Color Do You Buy 2 Shades Lighter?


@cuddlesmama wrote:

Recently Ihave been reading that when you buy boxed haircolor  you should go 2 shades lighter than what the box says so you hair won't comeout too dark.

Do you think this is true? I have never done that I have been always buying the same color Natural Instincts #20 brown and this time it came out so dark. I don't know if the formula changed or what. Now I finally have it gone and now I am considering just going to a salon to  see what color they would use.. Which I have never done. Do  you thaink salon color looks better than boxed color? Thanks


@cuddlesmama 

One of my friends has brown hair and she colors it herself and she found that to be true.  She was going by what looked to be her color on the box and the color came out really, really dark.  So, she told me she now goes a couple shades lighter and gets a better result.

 

As for myself, I haven't colored my hair for awhile but I used blonde shades.  I did go to  several salons for coloring and never liked the results.  I started doing the color myself and liked it much better.  So, I think personal experience varies.  

"A day without sunshine is like, you know, night." - Steve Martin
Respected Contributor
Posts: 2,807
Registered: ‎10-14-2016

Re: When You Buy Boxed Hair Color Do You Buy 2 Shades Lighter?

I've been coloring my own hair for years after not having good results at the hair salon.  Each time I went to the hair salon my hair would be a different color .....and this was after paying a lot of money.  Since then I've been using Nice N Easy.  I will say when they changed their numbers a few years ago I didn't know what number to use so I tried a few.....can't say I see a big difference in any of them near the same number.  Very gradual change between them.  I buy the boxes when they are on sale and I have a coupon.  Can usually color my hair now for $3.50. 

Honored Contributor
Posts: 15,453
Registered: ‎05-18-2017

Re: When You Buy Boxed Hair Color Do You Buy 2 Shades Lighter?

Yes @cuddlesmama .  I use Revlon Colorsilk to cover the minimal gray in my hair.  I use a lighter color to achieve the color I need.  I use Light Golden Brown or even Lightest Golden Brown to achieve a rich warm brown color. 

 

If I used a medium brown, it would come out way too dark.

 

Wen 1.jpg

Honored Contributor
Posts: 15,453
Registered: ‎05-18-2017

Re: When You Buy Boxed Hair Color Do You Buy 2 Shades Lighter?

Love the pic @StylishLady .