What is your Favorite Eyeliner?

Biftu · ‎02-05-2011

I have been using Mally eyeliner, but I'm running out and wonder if I should order again (they do work for me) or try something new. I have tried Tarte but these liners really burned me eyes so those are out.

RainyDayGal · ‎03-09-2010

Mally

Moonlady · ‎03-10-2010

NYX automatic eyeliner in bronze. Cheap, and lasts until I remove it.

What worries you masters you.

turtle52 · ‎03-15-2010

On 6/5/2014 Moonlady said:
NYX automatic eyeliner in bronze. Cheap, and lasts until I remove it.

This is my favorite also!!! I also am able to use it in my waterline and it stays and doesn't irritate my sensitive eyes. I stock up when Ulta has a BOGO and I am also able to use their coupon on the purchase.

FYI: Tarte eyeliners also burned my eyes and I returned them.

MoJoV · ‎10-01-2010

My favorite is Stila for eyeliner pencils. They stay on and donot smudge. They are pricey but worth it to me. I have tried NYX and it's good but does smudge a little after a long day. Tarte are THE WORST, mine arrived a mess and burned my eyes and I also returned them. Can't believe they sell junk like that.

Trees are the lungs of the Earth

turtle52 · ‎03-15-2010

On 6/5/2014 MoJoV said:
My favorite is Stila for eyeliner pencils. They stay on and donot smudge. They are pricey but worth it to me. I have tried NYX and it's good but does smudge a little after a long day. Tarte are THE WORST, mine arrived a mess and burned my eyes and I also returned them. Can't believe they sell junk like that.

I wonder which ingredient in the Tarte eyeliner burns our eyes. I have read about this problem many times on the boards. I called Tarte CS to try to find out why I might be having a problem, but they said that I was the only one who had complained to them.

sidsmom · ‎11-25-2011

Jordana FabuLiner Liquid Eye Liner...Walgreens. Learned about it here on these boards...thank you, Beauties! Like NYX recommended in post #2, cheap & lasts until I remove it.

ETA: I also have 2 pots of Bare Escentuals powder eyeliner & a special eyeliner brush...that I've been using close to a lifetime. Pretty solid eyeliner, but it needs water & a steady hand...not easy when I'm flying out the door!

NYC Susan · ‎03-13-2010

I literally cannot draw a straight line, so I've had a lot of problems finding an eyeliner that works for me. After trying everything, hands-down my favorite is Avon Glimmersticks.

It's interesting that I saw this thread now, since I was just about to order a few of the waterproof version for summer!

Kiss