Beauty

[Boehm Collector]

---

@nyc1 wrote:

@Shanus  I hate the tube mascara.  I tried Trish McEvoy tube mascara several times and it pulled off some of my eyelashes when I removed it.  Never again.  I'd rather use the regular waterproof mascara,  when I need it (vacation and special events) and just take more time removing it carefully.  

---

@nyc1 .. I don't think tubing mascara pulls off your lashes,  It's just the tubes coming off.   I have only used tubing mascara for years now.  

[Travone]

How timely...last week I lost my mascara....don't ask. 

Anyway there was no way I was going to a busy store before Christmas.   I stopped into the local drug store and bought the cheapest waterproof mascara they had....Wet n Wild  $3.99, and I love it.   No smearing or flaking. 

[nyc1]

---

@Boehm Collector wrote:

---

@nyc1 wrote:

@Shanus  I hate the tube mascara.  I tried Trish McEvoy tube mascara several times and it pulled off some of my eyelashes when I removed it.  Never again.  I'd rather use the regular waterproof mascara,  when I need it (vacation and special events) and just take more time removing it carefully.  

---

@nyc1 .. I don't think tubing mascara pulls off your lashes,  It's just the tubes coming off.   I have only used tubing mascara for years now.  

---

@Boehm Collector  I'm glad it works for you.  It didn't for me,  and I followed the directions perfectly.  

[justashopper]

I use and like L'Oreal Lash Paradise waterproof mascara.  Waterproof or tubing are the only ones that seem to not smear on me.  I must have watery eyes.  I also laugh and cry a lot.  LOL.  

I am planning to try the essence tubing, but I have not found it in stores.  It's always sold out in my area or not carried.  

[Etoile308]

People look for different things in a masacra. To me it really comes down to personal preference that I think can only be determined by trial and error. 

[Boehm Collector]

---

@nyc1 wrote:

---

@Boehm Collector wrote:

---

@nyc1 wrote:

@Shanus  I hate the tube mascara.  I tried Trish McEvoy tube mascara several times and it pulled off some of my eyelashes when I removed it.  Never again.  I'd rather use the regular waterproof mascara,  when I need it (vacation and special events) and just take more time removing it carefully.  

---

@nyc1 .. I don't think tubing mascara pulls off your lashes,  It's just the tubes coming off.   I have only used tubing mascara for years now.  

---

@Boehm Collector  I'm glad it works for you.  It didn't for me,  and I followed the directions perfectly.  

---

@nyc1 .. tubing mascara doesn't pull your lashes out.   What you are seeing at the tubes that surround the lashes.  

[Shelbelle]

I dont care for waterproof mascara, it seems like I can never really remove it, always looks black under my eyes after trying to remove it. 

[ID2]

Never waterproof, only washable. I would never use any removers near my precious eyes. Just soap,water and done.

[LTT1]

@charsha 

I recommend Wander Beauty serum mascara...it has health benefits for lashes.

[teganslaw]

---

@ID2 wrote:

Never waterproof, only washable. I would never use any removers near my precious eyes. Just soap,water and done.

---

What soap do you use to remove mascara? It seems that soap could also irritate your eyes, so it must be a mild one .