Reply
Respected Contributor
Posts: 4,533
Registered: ‎03-19-2010

@Boehm Collector wrote:

@nyc1 wrote:

@Boehm Collector wrote:

@nyc1 wrote:

@Shanus  I hate the tube mascara.  I tried Trish McEvoy tube mascara several times and it pulled off some of my eyelashes when I removed it.  Never again.  I'd rather use the regular waterproof mascara,  when I need it (vacation and special events) and just take more time removing it carefully.  


@nyc1 .. I don't think tubing mascara pulls off your lashes,  It's just the tubes coming off.   I have only used tubing mascara for years now.  


@Boehm Collector  I'm glad it works for you.  It didn't for me,  and I followed the directions perfectly.  


@nyc1 .. tubing mascara doesn't pull your lashes out.   What you are seeing at the tubes that surround the lashes.  


@Boehm Collector  That was not what I was seeing.  For some reason the Trish McEvoy mascara was very difficult to remove.  I tried it several times and both times I had issues.  I've always worn mascara and never had a problem removing any of them.  This was a tug!  Maybe different tube mascaras are different...  I'm sure they are, however,  this experience was enough for me.