I've never tried this. I love, love, love the Sephora Collection melting balm. It is only $10.00 and contains 4.2 ounces of product. This Seoul Cleansing Balm is double the price for less product.
The Sephora Collection balm does contain fragrance but I find it pleasant and it doesn't irritate my skin at all. It removes all of my make-up and then I follow-up with a gentle cream cleanser.