Beauty

[Harpa]

Or from Ulta.

This would be for my G-daughter. The only liquid I ever tried was a Lorac pen, which I have not used that much, since I like the Sephora pencils.

TIA!!

[Gramy24]

I have used Almay liquid eyeliner for many years! It actually lasts all day. I do use an eyelid primer first so don't know if that makes a big difference or not. I use the primer mainly for eyeshadows to not crease and be more lasting. I purchase it at Walmart but I'm sure most drug stores carry it.

[roxxy1]

Maybelline ultra waterproof liquid liner.

Stays all day, and looks great.  In black of course !

[JeanLouiseFinch]

Physicians Formula 2-in-1 Last Boosting Eyeliner & Serum.  While she might not actually need the lash boosting effects at her age, I think she might enjoy the ease of application.  This liner is in a tube that's about the size of a Bic stick pen.  The tip has some flexibility, lines easily, and lasts all day.  Available colors are Dark Brown, Black, and Ultra Black.  This was pretty much my go-to when I was wearing eyeliner everyday.  There's also a version in a short, stubby tube with a fatter, firm tip.  I didn't like that one at all so make sure you get the long, skinny one in the chrome look on the outside.

[Jacie]

The L'Oreal Wateproof Liquid Eyeliner is great, but it only comes in black. Easy lines thin or wide. I like the stylus application point.