My Smashbox eyebrow pencils in Taupe. Years ago when the Q sold Smashbox, I bought a lot of their items, one of which was this eye pencil which I absolutely adored. It wasn't waxy but it wasn't brittle either. It was just right. I think it came in a kit, although I can't remember for sure. I have about 8 various sized stubs left. I sharpened them so carefully but really, there's not much left of any of them. They were never sold again; when they were gone, they were gone forever. Now I only use them for special occasions when I want my eyebrows to look super-good.
I've never been able to find any other brand that came close to the consistency and this shade of taupe.
"That's a great first pancake."
Lady Gaga, to Tony Bennett