Beauty

[MemsGMa]

I agree.

[Irshgrl31201]

I have used both the pot liners and the stick liners and really like them both @SilleeMee. Sorry, I should have mentioned that in the earlier post.

[SilleeMee]

Thank you!  @Irshgrl31201

[Nataliesgramma]

 I prefer Laura Geller...but that is just me...

[febe1]

I've used both and am not happy with either. I prefer Skinn's gel liner. It's much better than both.

[Carolm]

I just ordered a 5 piece Laura Geller gel eyeliner set from Macy's for $27.00.  I purchased a similar set last year from QVC (I think) and was pleased with it. 

[jannabelle1]

I know you mentioned just Laura Geller or Malli, but I recently tried L'Oreal gel eyeliner pencil at Walgreen's, and it's great. It lasts all day - doesn't disappear after an hour or so like so many that I've tried over the years. I tried Malli some years ago and ended up throwing it away - didn't last. L'Oreal's liquid eyeliner also lasts all day - it's a much more fine/thin line than the jel pencil. JMO, but I've given up ordering eyeliner and mascara from the Q or HSN because of the price and shipping.

[Cardamom]

Definitely Mally!! I've tried both. I love Mally's liner. The only one I like more is Urban Decay. 

[soonersis]

---

@SilleeMee wrote:

Which Colourpop liners? They make more than one kind. @Irshgrl31201

---

I've tried both but much prefer the stick.  The pot one is much harder to apply, and the stick ones are easy and glide like butter.

[SilleeMee]

Thank you for recommending the Colourpop liners. I bought a black and a navy. They are super!

@soonersis @Irshgrl31201