There is no real definition for Clean. but for me any brand that is loaded with artificial dyes like Phil is in their body washes is far from Clean. The positive news for them is that they removed the harsh sulfates.
Mary Beth Roe just said the Philosophy Shower Gel is "all clean ingredients." I did not know they are Clean Beauty.
Philosophy is NOT in the "CLEAN BEAUTY" category of QVC skincare products. On the website you can find all the brands they sell which fit their description, meaning the absence of certain "unclean" ingredients such as "mineral oil", "phalates" and "petroleum by-products".