Beauty

[Pqfan]

Clinique Even Better Compact Makeup

Clinique High Impact Mascara

Clinique Soft Pessed Powder Blusher

Clinique Lipstick

Clinique Eyelining Pen

[Greeneyedlady21]

IT cc cream illumination 

Maybelline Great Lash mascara

Wet and Wild Reserve Your Cabana bronzer

Stila convertible color blush in Magnolia-it can be used on cheeks and lips

Maybelline Fit Me concealer

[Sooner]

Dior Foundation

Eyebrow pencil

Black tube-type Mascara

Clinique concealer in the clear tube

Guerlain peachy pink lipstick

That would absolutely do it for me!  

[aprilskies]

I would replace very little.  

Laura Geller Balance n Brighten 

[islandgrrl]

Urban Decay Eyeliner Gel Pencil in Corrupt

Anastasia Brow Powder duo in Dark Brown

Any decent black mascara

A raisin colored lip tint

And for the rare occasion that I use foundation: Hourglass in golden tan

[wilma]

I don’t consider SPF makeup but skincare so I didn't include it in my list even though I would never be without it. 

I would purchase:

Tinted moisturizer

Revlon superlustrous lipstick (can also use as blush)

Mascara

Eyeliner

Shine reducing finishing powder

[wagirl]

1)  brow/eyeliner

2)  moisturizer/spf combo

3)  lip balm

4)  cleanser

5)  korres OO serum

[depglass]

Easy

Benefit They're Real mascara

Benefit eyebrow pencil

Bare Escentuals original powder foundation

Bare Escentuals Glee for blush

Some nude matte lipstick ccurrently popular

[vermint]

Laura Geller Balance & Brighten

Laura Geller Blush in any one of several colors that I like...probably Pink Buttercream

Laura Geller Kajal Eyeliner in Dark Brown

CoverGirl LashBlast Mascara (orange tube) in Very Black

Burt's Bees Tinted Lip Balm in Rose or Red Dahlia (would depend on the season!)