Givenchy Black Magic question

Poodlepet2 · ‎03-09-2010

I love IT "Je nes sai quoi : it's a little different color every time I put it on, but it doesn't change to a horrid color if I have an acidic food. (Years ago I tried a mood match lipstick-it turned bright orange and I couldn't get it off!).

I like the hydration of IT, but the Givenchy looked really lush. Does anybody have any experience with this?

Poodlepet2

Sweet_Serenity · ‎01-22-2016

@Poodlepet2 wrote:
I love IT "Je nes sai quoi : it's a little different color every time I put it on, but it doesn't change to a horrid color if I have an acidic food. (Years ago I tried a mood match lipstick-it turned bright orange and I couldn't get it off!).

I like the hydration of IT, but the Givenchy looked really lush. Does anybody have any experience with this?

Poodlepet2

Omg!! IT Je nes awful shade on me!!!

Shelbelle · ‎03-09-2010

What about the green lippie from Lipstick Queen that turns pink? Je Ne Sai Quoi is OK on me, not my fave by any means.

Leeny · ‎06-24-2011

To @Poodlepet2: I do own the Givenchy Black Magic lipstick. I really like it as it turns into a pretty berry color on me. It is very lush as you say. I also got their gloss when the Q sold them together before Christmas.

Now for the IT Je nes sai quoi, I didn't care for the color that turned on me. It was like a bright fuscia color. I hope this helps you out.

Shelbelle · ‎03-09-2010

Remember Black Honey from Clinique, that is a lovely berry shade.

maestra · ‎03-09-2010

I recd the Givenchy as a deluxe bonus sample from Sephora and it turned my lips a lurid shade of hot pink!

Mood match lippie anyone?

Poodlepet2 · ‎03-09-2010

Maestra, that's scary-and it's not exactly inexpensive. I have never had problems with Je: it does change colors when you eat or drink, but the colors were always flattering....I think I will stick with the lippies I have!

Thanks for your timely response!

Poodlepet2

Kachina624 · ‎03-10-2010

How about the Mood Matchers lipsticks available at drugstores for a couple of dollars that also turn a pretty berry color that lasts for hours?

New Mexico☀️Land Of Enchantment

Tantallum · ‎02-16-2011

@Poodlepet2 wrote:
I love IT "Je nes sai quoi : it's a little different color every time I put it on, but it doesn't change to a horrid color if I have an acidic food. (Years ago I tried a mood match lipstick-it turned bright orange and I couldn't get it off!).

I like the hydration of IT, but the Givenchy looked really lush. Does anybody have any experience with this?

Poodlepet2

I LOVE this Givenchy product. It is very moisturizing. I wish they would stop calling it a lipSTICK because it is really a balm. I think it is more moisturizing than the IT Je nes sai quoi. It gives a lovely wash of color. On me it turns the most perfect deep berry shade. I have purchased two already so I have one at home and one at work. Has to be one of the best lip products I have ever bought. I hope they never stop making it!