Reply
Trusted Contributor
Posts: 1,136
Registered: ‎11-02-2010

Re: Eyeline that WON'T BUDGE - I am wasting money trying!

Bobbi Brown's Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner.  It comes in a little pot and you use a flat, thin eyeliner brush to apply it with.  You can sleep in it and your liner will still be in place in the morning. 

Honored Contributor
Posts: 26,898
Registered: ‎05-17-2010

Re: Eyeline that WON'T BUDGE - I am wasting money trying!


@TuesdayTaylor wrote:

Bobbi Brown's Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner.  It comes in a little pot and you use a flat, thin eyeliner brush to apply it with.  You can sleep in it and your liner will still be in place in the morning. 


 

 

@TuesdayTaylor  My #1 choice when I have the time to apply. On a daily basis I use Mally’s waterproof pencils. If you want to invest in a good, waterproof pencil, Trish McEvoy makes a Gel in Pencil form...about $30....a lot of money, but waterproof, smooth application, too.

Regular Contributor
Posts: 161
Registered: ‎07-31-2010

Re: Eyeline that WON'T BUDGE - I am wasting money trying!

Try Laura Geller's Kajal eyeliner. Wears like iron. It never budges or runs, even in the highest heat and humidity!. I have to use a separate eyeliner remover after washing my face to get the rest of it off. Truly the best I've used. And eyeliner is the the only thing I'll wear on my lids. No mascara and most of the time no shadow. 

Respected Contributor
Posts: 3,164
Registered: ‎09-25-2016

Re: Eyeline that WON'T BUDGE - I am wasting money trying!


@curlygirl2 wrote:

Try Laura Geller's Kajal eyeliner. Wears like iron. It never budges or runs, even in the highest heat and humidity!. I have to use a separate eyeliner remover after washing my face to get the rest of it off. Truly the best I've used. And eyeliner is the the only thing I'll wear on my lids. No mascara and most of the time no shadow. 


I second LG’s Kajal eyeliners. I am very oily, so very oily lids, and WI here is ridiculously humid and these eyeliners of hers don’t budge. They’re amazing!! 

Esteemed Contributor
Posts: 6,343
Registered: ‎05-18-2017

Re: Eyeline that WON'T BUDGE - I am wasting money trying!


@Shanus wrote:

@TuesdayTaylor wrote:

Bobbi Brown's Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner.  It comes in a little pot and you use a flat, thin eyeliner brush to apply it with.  You can sleep in it and your liner will still be in place in the morning. 


 

 

@TuesdayTaylor  My #1 choice when I have the time to apply. On a daily basis I use Mally’s waterproof pencils. If you want to invest in a good, waterproof pencil, Trish McEvoy makes a Gel in Pencil form...about $30....a lot of money, but waterproof, smooth application, too.


@Shanus- I haven't tried Trish's pencil yet.  I'm not excited about the $30.00, but if it doesn't run, it's worth it to me.  Mally's pencils didn't work well for me so I may take the plunge on Trish's.  HSN has free shipping (last time I checked) and I can return it if it doesn't work. 

Honored Contributor
Posts: 26,898
Registered: ‎05-17-2010

Re: Eyeline that WON'T BUDGE - I am wasting money trying!


@San Antonio Gal wrote:

@Shanus wrote:

@TuesdayTaylor wrote:

Bobbi Brown's Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner.  It comes in a little pot and you use a flat, thin eyeliner brush to apply it with.  You can sleep in it and your liner will still be in place in the morning. 


 

 

@TuesdayTaylor  My #1 choice when I have the time to apply. On a daily basis I use Mally’s waterproof pencils. If you want to invest in a good, waterproof pencil, Trish McEvoy makes a Gel in Pencil form...about $30....a lot of money, but waterproof, smooth application, too.


@Shanus- I haven't tried Trish's pencil yet.  I'm not excited about the $30.00, but if it doesn't run, it's worth it to me.  Mally's pencils didn't work well for me so I may take the plunge on Trish's.  HSN has free shipping (last time I checked) and I can return it if it doesn't work. 


@San Antonio Gal  20% off F&F sale on Trish site as of yesterday. Takes the sting out of the $30 liner.

 

Esteemed Contributor
Posts: 5,866
Registered: ‎03-09-2010

Re: Eyeline that WON'T BUDGE - I am wasting money trying!


@Sandgirl wrote:

I like to take my eyeliner all the way to the edge of upper then wing out just a tad, no matter what eyeliner I try, that "wing" never stays, it's gone in 3 hours after applying. Do you do this? If so, which one will stay at least most of the day?


 

@Shanus

Very pleased with Lisa Robertson's eyeliner.  For years the raccoon look or irritation's on the eye has plagued my search.  This lasts till you wash it off without being harsh.

Honored Contributor
Posts: 26,898
Registered: ‎05-17-2010

Re: Eyeline that WON'T BUDGE - I am wasting money trying!


@hopi wrote:

@Sandgirl wrote:

I like to take my eyeliner all the way to the edge of upper then wing out just a tad, no matter what eyeliner I try, that "wing" never stays, it's gone in 3 hours after applying. Do you do this? If so, which one will stay at least most of the day?


 

@Shanus

Very pleased with Lisa Robertson's eyeliner.  For years the raccoon look or irritation's on the eye has plagued my search.  This lasts till you wash it off without being harsh.


@hopi  LR now has cosmetics line? What?!?!?

Esteemed Contributor
Posts: 5,866
Registered: ‎03-09-2010

Re: Eyeline that WON'T BUDGE - I am wasting money trying!

[ Edited ]

@Shanus

 

 

She has done an oil with all types of good stuff in in but don't do oils on my skin for facial treatments. So it is something I am not interested in..

 

She did a video on her eyeliner and it is super controllable.  I really like it and am very fussy about eye make-up.  Only recommending it because I have tried everything and so far this is really working for me.

Honored Contributor
Posts: 26,898
Registered: ‎05-17-2010

Re: Eyeline that WON'T BUDGE - I am wasting money trying!


@hopi wrote:

@Shanus

 

 

She has done an oil with all types of good stuff in in but don't do oils on my skin for facial treatments. So it is something I am not interested in..

 

She did a video on her eyeliner and it is super controllable.  I really like it and am very fussy about eye make-up.  Only recommending it because I have tried everything and so far this is really working for me.


 

 

@hopi  Not to be rude, but really not interested in her or any of her products.