The reviews on Makeupalley are terrible; plus, the company does not accept returns.
I would suggest another cruelty-free lipstick brand called Red Apple Lipstick. Their CS is excellent, and they have a six-month return policy. You can create your own bundle and save money.
I have several of their lipsticks and like them all.
ETA: My apologies to the OP. I hope that no offense is taken. :-)
~Who in the world am I? Ah, that's the great puzzle~ Lewis Carroll, Alice in Wonderland