Every now & then I like to try new makeup techniques and looks. My latest is to forego mascara. I have good lashes. I don't need foundation. I have really good skin.
It's the blush - I've changed to a very soft shading, as I prefer to think of it - applied with a much softer brush.
I actually like to highlight, but it all has to do with placement! Like the old Hollywood makeup artists. I do not like highlight going up the sides of the eyes! A soft highlight - no Tin Man glow!
I think what we may be reading or hearing about that over a certain age to do lighter makeup....all has to do with how we are able to retain our skin tightness and its own luminosity. If your skin is slack, then you really do need a lighter hand in makeup application. That is, if you're going for a natural look.
But the bottom line is personal taste and skill in applying makeup, I guess, either for your enhancement, or maybe to make a statement.
But I think a natural look makes you look more youthful.