@patticakes I have been with Amerprise Ins, now called CONNECT, through Costco for several years.
I live in Michigan where auto ins has always been one of the highest with state law changing in the past few months and when my policy renews I'll be saving a lot . So I can't compare prices as just about every ins. companies rates have been similar. I called around and everyone was higher than CONNECT.
With CONNECT I pay a little more each month for 5 months and no payment on the 6th month. This works well for me and it's like having extra $$$ for my needs. BTW I also have renter's ins through them.
My SUV was hit and insurance was easy to deal with and handled swiftly so no complaints there.
Good luck finding what works for you.