topic Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems? in Wellness

Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

AngelPuppy1 — Tue, 14 Jan 2025 11:03:49 GMT

Has anyone here used either of these programs? If so, what did you think? Did you have good success? What was the food like?

I am thinking about doing one or the other. Each one seems pretty expensive. I have been trying to do something on my own but not having much success.

I am thinking that if I committed to paying this money and signing up for one of these that I will do better.

A long time ago I belonged to Jenny Craig but that was when a Jenny Craig was local and I could go in once a week for counseling and weigh-in and all that. There don't seem to be any of these any more.

Thoughts?

Thank you.

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

EllieMuncaster — Tue, 14 Jan 2025 12:52:18 GMT

15 years ago my husband and I lost weight on Nutrisystem. I thought the food tasted good, I can't remember how much we lost. For awhile I bought Nutrisystem food items "A la carte" after I stopped the monthly shipments.

One of the hardest things for me to lose weight is taking the time to plan my meals, when I don't plan I fail. No matter what weight loss plan I am on.

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

Neetgal2 — Tue, 14 Jan 2025 13:34:29 GMT

I have had luck on Nutrisystem, over 15 years ago after a weight gain from some meds!

It was easy for me to follow, as I was no longer cooking for my Dad. I have kept the weight off. I do take time to plan my meals and eat wisely. If I go off, like holidays and can't seem to get back, only talking 5 to 8 pounds, I go on slim fast, for no more than a month to get back to my proper weigh for my age and size. The Dr. knows I do this.

Good luck.

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

Puppy Lips — Tue, 14 Jan 2025 18:07:31 GMT

I went on Nutrisystem a few years back. I did lose weight. But frankly, I did NOT like some of the meals or many of the snacks. I ate some things that I detested. I think/hope their food has improved in taste. But, that stuff is full of chemicals and I wonder how good it is for you. The portions were small, so that is one reason you will lose weight.

I went off it and decided that I just need to make a plan that is a lifestyle change rather than a temporary fix. I did gain the weight back after I lost it on NS, but then lost it on my own with better eating and smaller portions.

Good luck to you. Losing weight and keeping it off is never easy, no matter how you do it.

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

Icegoddess — Tue, 14 Jan 2025 18:14:52 GMT

DH did Nutrisystem for quite awhile. However, he thought the food was AWFUL. He just did the basic program, not any of the ones you see advertised on TV which are more expensive, so he didn't get the shakes that are always touted on the HSN/QVC presentations. Know that the food will not be as large or tasty looking as it appears in the ads.

He currently uses the My Fitness Pal app and has been very impressed with it's capabilities. It has expanded on the MFP I used a few years ago. Many more chain restauarants in their database to track your intake. It's a fee app, or at least it was last time I used it.

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

Wsmom — Tue, 14 Jan 2025 18:21:32 GMT

@AngelPuppy1 , I tried Jenny Craig probably 15 years ago and had great success. Lost all the weight I needed to. The food was good.

My friends did Nutrisystem, again this is many years ago, and the food was so awful they stopped doing it. But this is probably 20 years ago. Hopefully the food has improved.

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

We rescue cats — Tue, 14 Jan 2025 20:08:12 GMT

We did it a few years ago, if you decide on Nutrisystem let me know, I still have a gift card to use on the frozen meals! (which we enjoyed!)

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

JudyL — Tue, 14 Jan 2025 23:56:31 GMT

I tried Jenny Craig years ago and had great success with it and liked the food a lot.

Also tried Nutrisystem and thought the food was just horrible and threw it out after 3 days Would never try it again.

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

chrystaltree — Wed, 15 Jan 2025 03:01:40 GMT

I tried them both several times back in the day. The only thing I lost was my money. I didn't like the taste of the food. I did better with the HMR Diet meal replacement entrees and shakes.

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

Tinkrbl44 — Wed, 15 Jan 2025 03:20:50 GMT

@AngelPuppy1 wrote:
Has anyone here used either of these programs? If so, what did you think? Did you have good success? What was the food like?

I am thinking about doing one or the other. Each one seems pretty expensive. I have been trying to do something on my own but not having much success.

I am thinking that if I committed to paying this money and signing up for one of these that I will do better.

A long time ago I belonged to Jenny Craig but that was when a Jenny Craig was local and I could go in once a week for counseling and weigh-in and all that. There don't seem to be any of these any more.

Thoughts?

Thank you.

@AngelPuppy1

I spent 30 days on Nutrisystem and lost just my money. I was surprised how much sugar was in those meals ... too many carbs! I followed it religiously, but no wonder I didn't lose any weight.

Later I spent a few months going to Lindora. They were using words like ketosis and low carb before I'd ever heard them anywhere else. I did exactly what they said to do and lost 23 pounds in 2 1/2 months.

If I wanted to lose weight again, I'd go to Lindora. It worked.

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

Tinkrbl44 — Wed, 15 Jan 2025 03:22:51 GMT

@EllieMuncaster wrote:
15 years ago my husband and I lost weight on Nutrisystem. I thought the food tasted good, I can't remember how much we lost. For awhile I bought Nutrisystem food items "A la carte" after I stopped the monthly shipments.
One of the hardest things for me to lose weight is taking the time to plan my meals, when I don't plan I fail. No matter what weight loss plan I am on.

@EllieMuncaster

Dr Thomas Gullo wrote a couple diet books and one of his affirmations was ....

PLANNING IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN WILL POWER.

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

Sooner — Wed, 15 Jan 2025 03:40:59 GMT

In the long run we found that a good app tracking everything you eat, making sure to get enough protein, calcium, and fiber (along with needed nutrients and vitamines) paid off. The app tracked most store brands and tons of foods.

We followed a combination of the Mediterreanean diet and the Mayo Clinic diet, the app set goals and we did great. You have to learn to eat in the real world, and simple non-processed food was the answer for us.

Also, a registered dietician is a great idea too! It was a help for us to get us started. Your doc might get you sessions insurance would pay for.

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

elated — Wed, 15 Jan 2025 07:54:23 GMT

@AngelPuppy1 I think the plan that works the best is Richard Simmons Deal A Meal. You can purchase on the website. You eat real food and you move cards. When the cards are gone, so is your food allowance..It is a good way to learn portion size and eat real food.

There are other plans that help you control your calories. The Factor is a good choice and it is all fresh food. You can choose from many entrees. It is less expensive than Nutri System and Jenny Craig.

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

ID2 — Wed, 15 Jan 2025 10:56:40 GMT

Complete waste of money! It's a proven fact after you stop using their meals the weight comes back on. Do this on your own! The key is to exercise. At least it was for me. I lost 70lbs and have kept it off now for 4 years. I've done it by eating no carb. It worked for me so I'm still eatng no carb. And I exercise every single day, along with weighing myself every single day. There is absolutely no excuse to being overweight. None at all. You have the power to do anything.

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

AngelPuppy1 — Wed, 15 Jan 2025 11:04:08 GMT

@EllieMuncaster wrote:
15 years ago my husband and I lost weight on Nutrisystem. I thought the food tasted good, I can't remember how much we lost. For awhile I bought Nutrisystem food items "A la carte" after I stopped the monthly shipments.
One of the hardest things for me to lose weight is taking the time to plan my meals, when I don't plan I fail. No matter what weight loss plan I am on.

@EllieMuncaster

Thank you. I appreciate your post.

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

AngelPuppy1 — Wed, 15 Jan 2025 11:04:45 GMT

@Neetgal2 wrote:
I have had luck on Nutrisystem, over 15 years ago after a weight gain from some meds!
It was easy for me to follow, as I was no longer cooking for my Dad. I have kept the weight off. I do take time to plan my meals and eat wisely. If I go off, like holidays and can't seem to get back, only talking 5 to 8 pounds, I go on slim fast, for no more than a month to get back to my proper weigh for my age and size. The Dr. knows I do this.

Good luck.

@Neetgal2

Thank you. I appreciate your posting.

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

AngelPuppy1 — Wed, 15 Jan 2025 11:05:17 GMT

@Puppy Lips wrote:
I went on Nutrisystem a few years back. I did lose weight. But frankly, I did NOT like some of the meals or many of the snacks. I ate some things that I detested. I think/hope their food has improved in taste. But, that stuff is full of chemicals and I wonder how good it is for you. The portions were small, so that is one reason you will lose weight.

I went off it and decided that I just need to make a plan that is a lifestyle change rather than a temporary fix. I did gain the weight back after I lost it on NS, but then lost it on my own with better eating and smaller portions.

Good luck to you. Losing weight and keeping it off is never easy, no matter how you do it.

@Puppy Lips

Thank you. I appreciate your honest reply.

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

AngelPuppy1 — Wed, 15 Jan 2025 11:06:07 GMT

@Icegoddess wrote:
DH did Nutrisystem for quite awhile. However, he thought the food was AWFUL. He just did the basic program, not any of the ones you see advertised on TV which are more expensive, so he didn't get the shakes that are always touted on the HSN/QVC presentations. Know that the food will not be as large or tasty looking as it appears in the ads.

He currently uses the My Fitness Pal app and has been very impressed with it's capabilities. It has expanded on the MFP I used a few years ago. Many more chain restauarants in their database to track your intake. It's a fee app, or at least it was last time I used it.

@Icegoddess

Thank you for your reply. Appreciated!

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

AngelPuppy1 — Wed, 15 Jan 2025 11:07:08 GMT

@Wsmom wrote:
@AngelPuppy1 , I tried Jenny Craig probably 15 years ago and had great success. Lost all the weight I needed to. The food was good.

My friends did Nutrisystem, again this is many years ago, and the food was so awful they stopped doing it. But this is probably 20 years ago. Hopefully the food has improved.

@Wsmom

I went on Jenny many years ago and I liked most of the food and did well. However, that was when you could go to an actual cliinic and meet weely and get counseled. Thanks!

Re: Thoughts on Jenny Craig or Nutrisystems?

AngelPuppy1 — Wed, 15 Jan 2025 11:07:31 GMT

@We rescue cats wrote:
We did it a few years ago, if you decide on Nutrisystem let me know, I still have a gift card to use on the frozen meals! (which we enjoyed!)

@We rescue cats

Thank you for your post. I appreciate it.