topic Re: EYE LINERS in Beauty

EYE LINERS

jellyBEAN — Sat, 09 May 2026 12:03:45 GMT

I don't wear makeup often, but when I do, I apply eye shadow, mascara and typically a liner - not black, but a shade of brown or any other color that looks good with brown eyes.

I am 68 and my eyelids are not as "flexible" as they used to be so applying eye makeup in general is a little trickier.

Can I get some recommendations for a decent eye liner that won't smear or transfer to the bottom, easy application, and isn't super duper expensive? My hair is gray now so I feel like I need a lift, maybe not a brown eye liner, but a different color that goes well with the gray hair and brown eyes.

Thanks for any suggestions. So many brands out there.

Re: EYE LINERS

Desertdi — Sat, 09 May 2026 12:18:10 GMT

My irises are hazel with spots of yellow, green, powder blue, and have a dark gray ring.

I use NYX "berry goth" eyeliner

Re: EYE LINERS

CorrTor — Sat, 09 May 2026 12:12:59 GMT

I really like Laura Geller's INKredible Waterproof Gel Eyeliner. It goes on really smoothly and it stays on all day, without smudging. There are also a lot of colors.

Re: EYE LINERS

LTT1 — Sat, 09 May 2026 12:21:31 GMT

@jellyBEAN

I have been pleased with NYX eyeliner...I like the liquid liner called NYX Professional Makeup EPIC INK LINER.

mine is black [it's the only one I have tried]

Reasonably priced, and there are many shades other than black to try. There is a brown. I have to sing the praises of NYX because they carry lots of choices of vegan options

This one does not transfer or smudge for me.

Re: EYE LINERS

Boehm Collector — Sat, 09 May 2026 13:05:40 GMT

L'Oreal Paris Cosmetics Paris Makeup Infallible Grip Precision Felt Eyeliner, Comes in several colors:

Re: EYE LINERS

bargainsgirl — Sat, 09 May 2026 13:10:11 GMT

I am nearly 73 and my lids are not 'smooth" any longer. So what I do is use a fine shadow brush, swipe it over the product, then over my lashline/lid and it creates a much softer look. I LOVE Skinn smudge sticks but I believe they are no longer available. I also use a dark shadow sometimes. I have dark brown eyes and light olive skin. Black is too harsh but any other color works for me.

Re: EYE LINERS

wagirl — Sun, 10 May 2026 14:27:57 GMT

I am using Mallys gel liners--have Laura Gellers big fat liners too--love the colors, but find the gel liners go on very smoothly. I cannot get the hang for the liquid liners tho---Am 71--for a few more weeks🤨--and my lids are doing fine. I usually line the waterline top and bottom. Haven't used LG liners as I thought they were making my eyes water--I have at least 8 of them all in different colors. Hate to toss them all so maybe will try them again.

Well I did try LG eyeliners again, yesterday and they made my eyes water and burn and so--prob will toss the bunch of them. Dang it--her colors are so nice and I paid prob close to $60--qvcs price---but not going to wear them again. Dang it!!!!

Re: EYE LINERS

Shelbelle — Sat, 09 May 2026 14:24:48 GMT

I also use the NYX perncils, but only the retractable pencils, I am 73 with green/hazel eyes, I use most all the shades except for the black, too harsh for me. One fave is Truffle Diamond, a greyish/brown. I use them mainly on the bottom rims. I dont think Berry Goth is retractable and needs sharpening.

Re: EYE LINERS

Judaline — Sat, 09 May 2026 14:21:24 GMT

@bargainsgirl wrote:
I am nearly 73 and my lids are not 'smooth" any longer. So what I do is use a fine shadow brush, swipe it over the product, then over my lashline/lid and it creates a much softer look. I LOVE Skinn smudge sticks but I believe they are no longer available. I also use a dark shadow sometimes. I have dark brown eyes and light olive skin. Black is too harsh but any other color works for me.

Yeah, one more big seller and he quits selling them. Go figure.

Re: EYE LINERS

JudyL — Sat, 09 May 2026 14:44:57 GMT

Another vote for Laura Geller's INKcredibile eye liners. They stay on and apply easily and are waterproof in case your eyes get watery. With her weekly, almost daily sales, you can get these at drugstore prices. Think I got an email today saying she's having a 50% off sale.

Re: EYE LINERS

rockygems123 — Sun, 10 May 2026 01:15:07 GMT

@jellyBEAN wrote:
I don't wear makeup often, but when I do, I apply eye shadow, mascara and typically a liner - not black, but a shade of brown or any other color that looks good with brown eyes.

I am 68 and my eyelids are not as "flexible" as they used to be so applying eye makeup in general is a little trickier.

Can I get some recommendations for a decent eye liner that won't smear or transfer to the bottom, easy application, and isn't super duper expensive? My hair is gray now so I feel like I need a lift, maybe not a brown eye liner, but a different color that goes well with the gray hair and brown eyes.

Thanks for any suggestions. So many brands out there.

@jellyBEAN

I like Maybelline Unstoppable eye liner pencil in Espresso.

I have brown eyes also and it is easy to apply have used it for years.

Re: EYE LINERS

JeanLouiseFinch — Sun, 10 May 2026 01:24:45 GMT

@jellyBEAN - a year or so ago I quit using traditional eyeliner and used a flat angled brush and dark eyeshadow or dark RMS brow powder. A few weeks ago I saw an ad for Sandstone Scandinavia Waterproof Eyeliner and was persuaded try it. It's a retractable pencil so no sharpening. Anyway, I bought black and I like it very much. It comes in an assortment of colors. It's on Amazon and the pencils cost about $12/$13.

Re: EYE LINERS

San Antonio Gal — Tue, 12 May 2026 12:36:23 GMT

@JeanLouiseFinch wrote:
@jellyBEAN - a year or so ago I quit using traditional eyeliner and used a flat angled brush and dark eyeshadow or dark RMS brow powder. A few weeks ago I saw an ad for Sandstone Scandinavia Waterproof Eyeliner and was persuaded try it. It's a retractable pencil so no sharpening. Anyway, I bought black and I like it very much. It comes in an assortment of colors. It's on Amazon and the pencils cost about $12/$13.

@JeanLouiseFinch - I'm always willing to try an eyeliner that doesn't run and is retractable. I prefer not to have to sharpen, but not a deal breaker. I just added this one to my upcoming order. Fingers crossed.

Re: EYE LINERS

kathie66 — Sun, 10 May 2026 12:46:43 GMT

@San Antonio Gal wrote:
@JeanLouiseFinch wrote:
@jellyBEAN - a year or so ago I quit using traditional eyeliner and used a flat angled brush and dark eyeshadow or dark RMS brow powder. A few weeks ago I saw an ad for Sandstone Scandinavia Waterproof Eyeliner and was persuaded try it. It's a retractable pencil so no sharpening. Anyway, I bought black and I like it very much. It comes in an assortment of colors. It's on Amazon and the pencils cost about $12/$13.

@JeanLouiseFinch - I'm always willing to try an eyeliner that doesn't run and retractable. I prefer not to have to sharpen, but not a deal breaker. I just added this one to my upcoming order. Fingers crossed.

@San Antonio Gal Me too! Especially in Navy, the color I use. In my cart too. Thanks @JeanLouiseFinch

Re: EYE LINERS

JeanLouiseFinch — Sun, 10 May 2026 13:39:03 GMT

@kathie66 wrote:
@San Antonio Gal wrote:
@JeanLouiseFinch wrote:
@jellyBEAN - a year or so ago I quit using traditional eyeliner and used a flat angled brush and dark eyeshadow or dark RMS brow powder. A few weeks ago I saw an ad for Sandstone Scandinavia Waterproof Eyeliner and was persuaded try it. It's a retractable pencil so no sharpening. Anyway, I bought black and I like it very much. It comes in an assortment of colors. It's on Amazon and the pencils cost about $12/$13.

@JeanLouiseFinch - I'm always willing to try an eyeliner that doesn't run and retractable. I prefer not to have to sharpen, but not a deal breaker. I just added this one to my upcoming order. Fingers crossed.

@San Antonio Gal Me too! Especially in Navy, the color I use. In my cart too. Thanks @JeanLouiseFinch

@San Antonio Gal & @kathie66 - I hope both of you like it.

Re: EYE LINERS

Sunshine Kate — Sun, 10 May 2026 13:46:34 GMT

@LTT1

Can the NYX eyeliner be used successfully on the lower waterline?

TIA

Re: EYE LINERS

Shanus — Mon, 11 May 2026 12:29:08 GMT

@jellyBEAN It seems like I've used "Urban Decay 24/7" liners forever. I like that I can sharpen them to a nice point.

The color selection is good, too. I have the black, dark grey, chocolate brown and navy.

I have grey hair too, but the above shades co-ordinate nicely with it. I don't use shadow on my lid anymore, but rather dot it between my lashes and also tightline.

Re: EYE LINERS

pigletsmom2 — Mon, 11 May 2026 12:44:59 GMT

Julep gel eyeliner. Stays put and goes on super easy. I'll probably never waste time trying another. Their site always offers sales and I think has free shipping at 40 bucks. Amazon also sells them and right now a little cheaper so if you have prime you can free ship one to try. Sometimes they even offer sales through amazon which is why I tried them to being with.

Re: EYE LINERS

Carolina925 — Tue, 12 May 2026 10:55:21 GMT

I'm in my 70s and wear eye liner every day. After trying everything, I finally found one that works for me: Sephora's 12 Hour Retractable liner in matte brown. They offer different colors, which I've tried, but the brown works best for me. Green eyes, hooded lids, dirty blonde hair with gray "highlights". I always use NARS eyelid primer first. This liner stays on all day long, even in the summer humidity. I think I pay around $12 for it, which is a plus! Retractable is a necessity for me, can't use those liquid liners. I have to order two at a time, however, because the pencil isn't see through and there's no warning that you're at the end.

Re: EYE LINERS

10sluvr — Tue, 12 May 2026 12:31:45 GMT

@bargainsgirl wrote:
I am nearly 73 and my lids are not 'smooth" any longer. So what I do is use a fine shadow brush, swipe it over the product, then over my lashline/lid and it creates a much softer look. I LOVE Skinn smudge sticks but I believe they are no longer available. I also use a dark shadow sometimes. I have dark brown eyes and light olive skin. Black is too harsh but any other color works for me.

76 here and liked the Skinn smudge sticks too, but i thought they were too wide/thick but good colors.