topic Re: Concealer comparisons in Beauty

Concealer comparisons

smoochy — Sun, 12 Jan 2025 18:21:42 GMT

Tarte shape tape vs IT bye bye dark spots (I currently use) I see that QVC is having some specials on Tarte

or something else? I use concealer in inner corners of eyes to cover/lighten dark areas. Also to cover discoloration like age spots. Thanks for input

Re: Concealer comparisons

JeanLouiseFinch — Wed, 15 Jan 2025 15:20:46 GMT

@smoochy wrote:
Tarte shape tape vs IT bye bye dark spots (I currently use) I see that QVC is having some specials on Tarte

or something else? I use concealer in inner corners of eyes to cover/lighten dark areas. Also to cover discoloration like age spots. Thanks for input

Of the two you named, @smoochy, I much prefer the IT Bye Bye Dark Spots. I never liked Shape Tape. I mostly use the BBDS dotted under the eye for a little brightening, but I've also used it for some age spots. I also have the RMS concealer that goes with my RMS foundation.

Skincare wise, there are products that address dark spots too. Sometimes it's trial and error, if they are effective or not.

Re: Concealer comparisons

Shanus — Mon, 13 Jan 2025 11:06:20 GMT

@JeanLouiseFinch @smoochy I've tried both and can't use either. Even with an emollient eye cream, I find they are too thick for me and difficult to apply.

Re: Concealer comparisons

Dazlin — Mon, 13 Jan 2025 13:34:41 GMT

I agree with @Shanus , those are too thick and yellow.

I like Mac prep n prime...but only a teeny dot.

I saw one with pink undertones on Sephora, think it's called Kosa...I may have the name wrong?? But it looked nice. I'm ALWAYS hunting for undereye concealer or brightener that doesn't crease without doing a thousand pats and steps 🤨

Re: Concealer comparisons

wagirl — Mon, 13 Jan 2025 14:48:02 GMT

I like shape tape---am wondering if any of you use a damp sponge to tap it in? It is thick but using a sponge works so well for me. I use the egg shaped one--well a dupe ---and I really like the results.

Re: Concealer comparisons

Shanus — Tue, 14 Jan 2025 11:41:41 GMT

@monicakm I'm loving the Dior concealer in 1N that matches my stick foundation. Rarely worn though since I got hooked on the Merit Minimalist Perfecting Sticks...even better than WE and so much more economical. I can also use it as concealer since it's so creamy. NARS Radient Concealer is a winner, too.

Re: Concealer comparisons

MrsCat21 — Tue, 14 Jan 2025 14:02:02 GMT

I have found Shape Tape to be too thick for me. I love It Bye Bye Dark Spots and I actually use it all over, I just bought the Doll 10 Skin Genius Concealer with Reishi Mushtoom, waiting for delivery. Looks like It blends out nice. We will see. I have a tough time under the eyes...

Re: Concealer comparisons

Dazlin — Tue, 14 Jan 2025 20:00:49 GMT

@Shanus @monicakm ...do you use those under your eyes?? How's the creasing?...I'd like to look into them...and maybe there's a shade with a bit of pink .

Re: Concealer comparisons

Jacie — Wed, 15 Jan 2025 00:37:18 GMT

The only Shape Tape I can use is the new creamy version. Natasha Denona is amazing as well as ELF Hydrating Camo concealer, I gave up on many others!

Re: Concealer comparisons

CANDLEQUEEN — Tue, 14 Jan 2025 20:38:56 GMT

My favorite concealer is Natasha Denona. Its not cheap, but it lasts quite a while. I only use for under my eyes, not all over, so I am really getting my money's worth. It is not thcik but it is not thin, and it covers really well, and does not settle......Love it!

Re: Concealer comparisons

Shanus — Tue, 14 Jan 2025 23:51:00 GMT

@Dazlin Do you mean NARS? Any concealer I use under my eyes I mix in my hand w/ a bit of under eye cream. This thins it down and also helps eliminate creasing because it adds hydration. I also don't set my concealer with powder. When I apply it, I let it set for a few minutes before smoothing it under eyes and tapping it on with my finger or a damp sponge.

I use the same shade of concealer for under eyes as I do on my face to spot conceal. A big mistake some make is too light a concealer shade which draws attention to that area. It used to be the "rule" to go a shade lighter, but it's too obvious.

Re: Concealer comparisons

Shanus — Tue, 14 Jan 2025 23:54:27 GMT

@Dazlin wrote:
@Shanus @monicakm ...do you use those under your eyes?? How's the creasing?...I'd like to look into them...and maybe there's a shade with a bit of pink .

@Dazlin If you have bluish/purple darkness under your eyes, a shade w/ peach under tones instead of pink will be better...but don't go too far off the color of the rest of your face.

Re: Concealer comparisons

Dazlin — Wed, 15 Jan 2025 13:48:20 GMT

@Shanus , yes I was asking about the concealers both you and @monicakm used. I can't really say my under eye area is disclored or darkened ...its more sunken. We have spoken about this in the past, and I bought both of Bobby Brown concealer and corrector (you suggested)

I'm finished them and as usual I continue to hunt.

I think I like something more brightening that gives the illusion of plumpness. Two I now use are Maybelline Rewind concealer and Mac Prep n Prime

I apply over my eye cream and they crease like crazy.

I'll try your method next. TY

Re: Concealer comparisons

KKJ — Wed, 15 Jan 2025 14:56:47 GMT

I've used every concealer out there and the one I'm hooked on & rave about now is from Monika Blunder. She had a show on Q awhile back but don't know if her products are still available here.

Re: Concealer comparisons

snipsnapsnur — Wed, 15 Jan 2025 15:06:51 GMT

The only under eye concealer that I have found that works beautifully is Mally's Dark Circle Corrector. The maroon twist up pen. I apply it after using my Algenist Triple Algae Eye Renwal Balm (it's really more of a thin cream than a balm). The concealer NEVER settles in creases. I apply 3 light dotted areas of it and smooth it in with my finger. A little goes a long way.