topic The Worst Mascara Ever in Beauty

The Worst Mascara Ever

shaggygirl — Fri, 28 Feb 2020 14:06:25 GMT

Katy Perry's Katy Kat Eye. What a thick glommy mess and horrible applicator.

If she used this herself she'd probably take it off the market rather than have her name associated with it.

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

FlowerBear — Fri, 28 Feb 2020 14:25:56 GMT

Thank you for telling us about it

I never buy celebrity products, just because their name is on it means nothing to me

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

KingstonsMom — Fri, 28 Feb 2020 14:32:30 GMT

@FlowerBear

I agree and just because their name is on it doesn't mean that they use it.

We all know they don't do their own makeup, they have makeup artists to do that and makeup artists use their preferred makeup brands.

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

shaggygirl — Fri, 28 Feb 2020 14:35:53 GMT

My granddaughter is stopping here in a little while. She's in her mid twenties and into makeup. I give her all my make-up & hair stuff that I try and don't care for. I took it out of the can and am going to have her give it a try, see what she thinks.

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

rms1954 — Fri, 28 Feb 2020 15:46:33 GMT

I think anything with her name on it a young wanna be girl would purchase. I mean use your head, what does she know about mascara. She's a singer. She gets money with her name on it.

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

SilleeMee — Fri, 28 Feb 2020 15:51:57 GMT

The reviews for that mascara don't look too good. For instance, MakeupAlley gave an average 2.1 star rating. Ulta gave it a 2.4.

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

shaggygirl — Fri, 28 Feb 2020 15:57:39 GMT

@SilleeMee wrote:
The reviews for that mascara don't look too good. For instance, MakeupAlley gave an average 2.1 star rating. Ulta gave it a 2.4.

@SilleeMee

I was at the grocery store (hair/makeup aisle) looking for my Covergirl Clump Crusher & spotted hers since it's also a Covergirl product and thought eh, I'll give it a try. Should have passed on it till I read reviews like you did.

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

Katcat1 — Fri, 28 Feb 2020 16:03:11 GMT

Another horrible mascara is washable mascara. It flakes off, it clumps on the lashes.

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

MomCat — Fri, 28 Feb 2020 16:38:29 GMT

@FlowerBear wrote:
Thank you for telling us about it

I never buy celebrity products, just because their name is on it means nothing to me

Yes! My policy as well. Never have even been tempted.

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

Lipstickdiva — Fri, 28 Feb 2020 16:41:21 GMT

I don't buy a celebrity product just because their name is on it but I also don't completely disregard a product because it has a celebrity name on it either. That's just silly. I am willing to give most things a try unless i have a real problem with the celebrity.

I am very glad I tried the Haus Laboratories lip products by Lady Gaga becase they are fabulous.

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

JustJazzmom — Fri, 28 Feb 2020 16:51:06 GMT

I had received a sample of Urban Decay Troublemaker. It contained visible fibers in the formula that I initially thought were eyelashes! I thought the product was used by someone else. It wasn't.

Troublemaker got eventually discontinued because of all the bad reviews-- product too long to dry on lashes, the fibers in the formula. The container was a holographic rainbow which was the only thing nice I could say about it. I think if they used the container for a LE Perversion, I might buy it.

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

LuvmyLab — Fri, 28 Feb 2020 20:19:16 GMT

It Cosmetics superhero mascara is the worst! Clumps, flakes and looks horrible on.

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

Nadine O — Fri, 28 Feb 2020 20:39:21 GMT

I am so sensitive to mascara and have yet to find one that I am totally in love with. I think I have tried just about every kind and still have no real winners. I have tried two Tarte ones and don't like those either. Clearly I won't be trying Katy Perry's for sure. Thanks for the heads up!

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

jpie — Fri, 28 Feb 2020 20:46:33 GMT

@LuvmyLab wrote:
It Cosmetics superhero mascara is the worst! Clumps, flakes and looks horrible on.

-----

I agree, it is bad. I have tried twice with the Superhero. I will not buy a kit that has it thrown into the mix. I do love the iT Tightliner mascara though! If I want really big lashes, I use Lancome Hypnose Drama on top of the Tightliner.

I also had terrible luck with Loreal Lash Paradise mascara.

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

AvalonRose — Fri, 28 Feb 2020 21:00:33 GMT

I used to buy Mally's 6 pack so I'd never run out but lately it's just been terrible so I'm done with her. Usually I love Mally's stuff -- don't like watching her but lover her products.

I just purchases Benefit Better than Sex Mascara....I'll let you know hahahaha

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

fitfuninformed — Fri, 28 Feb 2020 21:08:36 GMT

@AvalonRose Better Than Sex Mascara is from TwoFaced - I do not care for that mascara at all.

Benefit offers a mascara called [something] They're Real which I DO like, both the formula and the brush; however, it is waterproof which I prefer not to wear on a daily basis but is great for an event!

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

AvalonRose — Fri, 28 Feb 2020 21:14:45 GMT

@fitfuninformed Thank you for the information. You are right it is TooFaced I'm getting my brands mixed up. I will look for the Benefit one next time I'm at the mall. Finding the right mascara is crucial. I don't like the waterproof either for everyday, I wear contacts and sometimes they flake.

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

TY — Sat, 29 Feb 2020 01:17:30 GMT

@shaggygirl

The Katy Perry Covergirl mascara is being discontinued in Canada and I've seen it marked down or in the clearance bins up here. Good to know that it's not a very good mascara.

I find mascaras so hit and miss as to whether I like them or not no matter what brand it is.

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

shaggygirl — Sat, 29 Feb 2020 13:19:46 GMT

So I had my 26 yr old granddaughter give it a try. She said "eww, throw it back in the garbage can".

Re: The Worst Mascara Ever

ajsidney12 — Sat, 29 Feb 2020 23:50:54 GMT

My go-to's are always prime with Tightline by IT, then Bad Gal by Benefit (really separates and holds curl) or Perversion by UD, and Dior. They take forever to get off even with using Lancome eye makeup remover though. I always use an eyelash curler. I have used LG GlamLASH mascara but found they dried out quickly, but I liked them!

Bad experiences with the new Mally mascara (the white tube was my HG forever!) , IT all of them, except Tightline, Lash Paradise, and most drugstore brands they just flake off and do not hold curl the way I like.