topic Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin in Beauty

Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

WenDoll10girl — Wed, 08 Apr 2015 15:05:13 GMT

Hello everyone. I would appriciate any recommendations as to these products. I'm deciding if I should buy the LG TSV. I am almost out of my BE. I have a few questions. Which one do you prefer? Is LG good for sensitive skin? How is porcelain vs fair? Is the fair on LG too dark? I use fair for BE, but I remember reading somewhere LG shades tend to be too dark. Any suggestions are greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance.

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

nodecaf — Wed, 08 Apr 2015 15:38:03 GMT

I always ""feel"" LG BnB on my skin whereas BE is as light as air.

You'd probably be PORCELAIN in LG.

I have never had any skin issues with LG.

My preference goes to BE Matte foundation (which is not really matte at all).

HTH

(dry/reactive)

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

WenDoll10girl — Wed, 08 Apr 2015 15:50:22 GMT

Thanks. What is BNB?

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

Jeannie29 — Wed, 08 Apr 2015 16:45:40 GMT

On 4/8/2015 Newtowen said: Thanks. What is BNB?

Bnb =balance and brighten

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

Josea922 — Wed, 08 Apr 2015 17:11:51 GMT

I think you would need to order porcelain in LG if you are fair in BE. I wear BE fairly light and LG fair is almost too dark for me.

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

WenDoll10girl — Wed, 08 Apr 2015 17:24:44 GMT

On 4/8/2015 Jeannie29 said:
On 4/8/2015 Newtowen said: Thanks. What is BNB?
Bnb =balance and brighten

Thank you.

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

WenDoll10girl — Wed, 08 Apr 2015 17:26:41 GMT

On 4/8/2015 Josea922 said:
I think you would need to order porcelain in LG if you are fair in BE. I wear BE fairly light and LG fair is almost too dark for me.

Thank you. I think I will then order porcelain, before that one runs out.

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

ginabfly — Wed, 08 Apr 2015 18:14:56 GMT

I do like both, but I prefer BE, and it's easier to find a matching shade. LG's is tricky, because if there's too much yellow running through the BnB then it doesn't match me. I wear Fairly Medium to Medium in BE, and in LG I wear Fair, unless there's too much yellow running through it, then I can't wear it. I also feel like BE's coverage lasts longer that LG's.

I can't speak about LG's porcelain, or whether or not it's okay for sensitive skin. My skin is pretty normal but it can occasionally have a reaction to something, and I've never had a reaction when using BE or LG.

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

ginabfly — Wed, 08 Apr 2015 18:28:14 GMT

Also I agree, if you're Fair in BE, then Fair in LG would be too dark, and Porcelain may work.

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

WenDoll10girl — Wed, 08 Apr 2015 21:07:39 GMT

Thank you all. It seems like a great deal. Any of you getting it?

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

Naryn — Wed, 08 Apr 2015 22:49:45 GMT

I wear the fair in BE (original loose) and found the LG in porcelain to be too white and powdery looking on my skin, but that really depends on the main colors you get in your individual compact. I felt mine ran light and would have liked a bit more beige in it, but it had the perfect amount of pink. I liked how it applied and I don't mind adding a bit of bronzer or something to warm it up a touch and it covered my redness well, however by the afternoon I could definitely feel the BnB on my face. I have dry skin so it isn't like it's oil coming through and this is the only product I have used that does this, but it just felt thick and yucky by 6-8 hours later. I never feel BE on my skin like that, even if I add more, touch up or use mineral veil. It totally made me feel EWWW and I just wanted to wash it off halfway through my day. That was the deal breaker for me, and yes I did give it a fair shot (more than 3 months).

I think you should give it a try and see for yourself how it does. At least with Q's return policy you know you aren't stuck with it if it doesn't work for you.

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

kalicat — Thu, 09 Apr 2015 07:03:12 GMT

I have used both BE and Laura Geller. I find that the LG can give more coverage, depending on the kind of brush you use. It tends to puddle less in the small wrinkles or creases and BE is bad about that. Also, BE has the ingredient Bismuth in it that makes my skin sting and burn if I get hot and start sweating. Overall, I prefer LG.

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

sipp — Thu, 09 Apr 2015 07:12:23 GMT

Try Baked Elements by Laura Geller instead of Balance and Brighten-- I used to use B&B exclusively but it's not always the same ""mix""--- I used BE when I was younger but now it shows creases and I also found it did bother me ( they won't let me write {itcsh} (remove the ""s"" and you'll get the word) in the summer---- I don't even know (and neither does anyone else) that I'm wearing it and I have mild rosacea - it covers well and doesn't settle in creases or irritate me. I wish she'd have more TSV's with the Baked Elements.

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

WenDoll10girl — Thu, 09 Apr 2015 11:11:09 GMT

Thanks. I now have the porcelain TSV in my cart, my only worry now before I purchase, is whether anyone has experienced acne breakouts from it, but from your comments it does not seem that is the case. Also as Kalicat, with BE I have sometimes experienced a slight burning sensation after applying it. Thankfully, it has been when I don't wear my zinc CC under it and only for a couple of minutes. I guess my skin was more sensitive in those days, but it did not make me break out.. I really want to find a line that is gentle enough for my skin, is paraben free, does not break me out and is cruelty free.

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

Rachb — Thu, 09 Apr 2015 12:20:05 GMT

On 4/9/2015 dgluvr said:
Try Baked Elements by Laura Geller instead of Balance and Brighten-- I used to use B&B exclusively but it's not always the same "mix"--- I used BE when I was younger but now it shows creases and I also found it did bother me ( they won't let me write {itcsh} (remove the "s" and you'll get the word) in the summer---- I don't even know (and neither does anyone else) that I'm wearing it and I have mild rosacea - it covers well and doesn't settle in creases or irritate me. I wish she'd have more TSV's with the Baked Elements.

I switched to Baked Elements because the color is consistent. I'm light in Bareminerals and I use porcelain in the baked elements. BnB is too inconsistent with color. Because of the marbleized color, sometimes you get more pinks, yellows, browns, etc. I had to buy both porcelain and fair in BnB and try to concoct my own mix on my face to get the right color. I got tired of that and I've been pretty happy with the Baked Elements.

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

WenDoll10girl — Fri, 10 Apr 2015 03:06:21 GMT

On 4/9/2015 RachB said:
On 4/9/2015 dgluvr said:
Try Baked Elements by Laura Geller instead of Balance and Brighten-- I used to use B&B exclusively but it's not always the same "mix"--- I used BE when I was younger but now it shows creases and I also found it did bother me ( they won't let me write {itcsh} (remove the "s" and you'll get the word) in the summer---- I don't even know (and neither does anyone else) that I'm wearing it and I have mild rosacea - it covers well and doesn't settle in creases or irritate me. I wish she'd have more TSV's with the Baked Elements.

I switched to Baked Elements because the color is consistent. I'm light in Bareminerals and I use porcelain in the baked elements. BnB is too inconsistent with color. Because of the marbleized color, sometimes you get more pinks, yellows, browns, etc. I had to buy both porcelain and fair in BnB and try to concoct my own mix on my face to get the right color. I got tired of that and I've been pretty happy with the Baked Elements.

After reading your comments. I'm still debating now it I should submit my order. I keep seeing mixed reviews. My main concern is skin sensitivity, but I would not like it if the color is too yellow.

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

sipp — Fri, 10 Apr 2015 05:23:29 GMT

On 4/9/2015 Newtowen said:
On 4/9/2015 RachB said:
On 4/9/2015 dgluvr said:
Try Baked Elements by Laura Geller instead of Balance and Brighten-- I used to use B&B exclusively but it's not always the same "mix"--- I used BE when I was younger but now it shows creases and I also found it did bother me ( they won't let me write {itcsh} (remove the "s" and you'll get the word) in the summer---- I don't even know (and neither does anyone else) that I'm wearing it and I have mild rosacea - it covers well and doesn't settle in creases or irritate me. I wish she'd have more TSV's with the Baked Elements.

I switched to Baked Elements because the color is consistent. I'm light in Bareminerals and I use porcelain in the baked elements. BnB is too inconsistent with color. Because of the marbleized color, sometimes you get more pinks, yellows, browns, etc. I had to buy both porcelain and fair in BnB and try to concoct my own mix on my face to get the right color. I got tired of that and I've been pretty happy with the Baked Elements.
After reading your comments. I'm still debating now it I should submit my order. I keep seeing mixed reviews. My main concern is skin sensitivity, but I would not like it if the color is too yellow.

I know that that TSV seems tempting (and it always is a great deal) but do a comparison of pictures of the products to see what I and others are telling you--- (they carry both on QVC, also on her site, and at some Ulta stores)- Even just a picture will show you the difference- the B&B has swirls of mixed colors (which as said before - do vary from time to next time you order) whereas the newer baked ELEMENTS is one color. Then choose- If it's the TSV for today (April 9.2015) -- that you're debating on- you have time to check the other..

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

kalicat — Fri, 10 Apr 2015 08:29:34 GMT

I have never had a problem with sensitivity with the LG Baked & Brighten. I am Irish, redheaded, blue eyes, fair skin that reacts to almost everything. This is my go-to makeup. It is quick, easy, looks like you're not wearing anything so you look natural only better, don't feel it on my face, stays on most all day (I hardly every touch it up). I am older and have decided that the BE is just not good for me. I can't stand the stinging when the weather turns hot. It goes into creases, etc. I wouldn't worry about having a reaction to the LG powder makeup. I don't care for her primer or hardly any primers because they are mostly cones that make my face break out. By the way, I ordered the TSV. HTH

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

hopi — Fri, 10 Apr 2015 11:00:56 GMT

I have used both and fall into the very sensitve skin category and BE made my skin worse.

LG is so much easier to use , more of a natural look and has never caused a problem for my skin.

Re: Laura Geller vs Bare Minerals for sensitive skin

WenDoll10girl — Fri, 10 Apr 2015 11:27:11 GMT

Thank you kalicat and hopi. I have been wanting to try something gentler than BE. Like you said, sometimes I notice a sting on my face after applying it. I don't really notice it if I use it over my cc. However, since I'm almost out of it I thought this would be a good opportunity to change lines. Thanks again.