topic Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say? in Beauty

IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

momshan — Sat, 14 Mar 2015 23:49:17 GMT

Does it grab those little eyelashes? Does it curl them and keeps that curl all day?

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

Kind1too — Sat, 14 Mar 2015 23:59:13 GMT

It does mine.

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

ashleycatie10 — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 00:21:16 GMT

Yes this is a very good product.I hope this helps

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

January121 — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 00:40:44 GMT

Yes, it is a great mascara .... I however, cannot get it close enough to my upper eye line to get it to look like I have eyeliner on .. I still love it and always order it.

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

Jacie — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 00:50:38 GMT

It is my go to mascara, but I prefer the waterproof formula.

I use it alone everyday. For an amped up look I will put Blinc mascara on top of it

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

Crisso — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 01:02:16 GMT

Yep. This and Blinc are my faves. IT for daily wear and Blinc if I want more wow! I already have long lashes, so most of the regular wands make me look like I have spiders! My lashes tend to be "straight" so I still need to use an eyelash curler with IT Tightline.

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

Desi — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 01:49:07 GMT

Didn't care for it - it's either love or hate on this one.

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

author — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 01:53:11 GMT

It certainly wasn't for me either, took forever to get any mascara to stick to my lashes, never got the tightline look, and it smudged badly too. I used up my wand and kept hoping for better results, but finally was was so relieved to go back to Lancome.

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

sharlee — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 02:13:45 GMT

I could never really get the "tightline' effect either, but I do think it makes a great lash primer - a black primer is such a good idea.

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

happygolfcartrider — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 03:10:47 GMT

Question about IT eyebrow products, I use the pencil and love it but the gel looks interesting. Which is the best for stay power and looking natural?

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

cotto22 — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 04:45:54 GMT

I love it. One of the few mascara products that separates my lashes and doesn't end up on my cheeks. It does give a little line, but not as much as they say!

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

Nicole WI — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 05:12:46 GMT

I love it in the waterproof formula and seriously am never without a backup tube. I have plenty of lashes, but I prefer a natural look (unless it is a special occasion or situation where I want a bit bolder look) and this does that for me and stays until I remove it. I don't use it for the tightline effect so I can't say for certain that you won't need separate eyeliner, and it does lift your lashes so your eyes appear more open and awake. I would not use the word "curl" just because when I think of curled eyelashes I think of lashes that have more of a defined "C" shape to them. This lifts the lashes so they do not look straight or have no bend to them at all, but does not in my opinion look like a curled eyelash. Anyway, I love the stuff and won't be without it!

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

hsj — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 05:38:45 GMT

I think I found a dupe. The Skinny mascara by NYX at Ulta...$7! I love it.

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

blueskies — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 05:43:11 GMT

It was included in the TsV last year . I couldn't get it to make an eyeliner line , as much as I tried . I don't remember any instruction / advice in the kit either , which might have been helpful . As far as a mascara , it seemed the same as any other brand . It didn't curl my lashes ; mechanical eyelash curlers give me the creeps , lol, so I was hoping that brush would do that . I returned the TSV because I didn't care for the type of foundation in it . I'm using one of her other foundation formulas now & love it .

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

Janey2 — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 13:56:09 GMT

This was the best purchase I ever made on QVC. I wear it during the day when I want a very thin line of eyeliner. Under mascara it is a great primer.

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

Himi lover — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 14:13:40 GMT

I didn't like the tight line mascara. My go to mascara is by Peter Thomas Roth, and I've tried them all. Most mascaras make my lashes look clumpy and they stick together. Not PTRs. The person who asked about the gel eyebrow product, I like it very much. Bit of a learning curve there, but it works great. I also was using the IT YBBB pencil, and like that too but the gel better.

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

Shelbelle — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 15:02:51 GMT

I really like it as a stand alone mascara, but did it actually look like I was also wearing eyeliner, not really.

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

Pecky — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 15:06:20 GMT

I love it. It gives a natural look like you aren't wearing any mascara. It doesn't clump at all always a perfect application.

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

Pook — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 15:14:31 GMT

Did absolutely nothing for my lashes and I also like waterproof. No matter what anyone says I need to curl my lashes and this just straightens them and they stick straight out. Doesn't even work on my lower lashes. Not for me.

Re: IT cosmetics Tightline. As good as they say?

Bellabetty — Sun, 15 Mar 2015 15:29:49 GMT

I would buy this in a second if it came in brown. Black is way too harsh for my 68 yr old eyes !!