topic Question...Josie M argon milk in Beauty

Question...Josie M argon milk

MarR — Tue, 25 Nov 2014 08:09:37 GMT

Wasn't sure what category to post this under. I have been using the milk product and love it. My newest bottle is yellow not white like the others. Anyhow have thoughts on this? Keep as it is okay or returnable? Thanks.

Re: Question...Josie M argon milk

bunjetto — Tue, 25 Nov 2014 09:40:38 GMT

I purchased the Milk when it first came out that bottle was off white and creamy. I then got the TSV with the Milk and this one is bright white and a chalky texture. Not sure what to think. I do know that I liked the first bottle better than the TSV one. Sorry I couldn't help.

Re: Question...Josie M argon milk

MarR — Tue, 25 Nov 2014 19:18:03 GMT

Thanks bunjetto. It is good to hear your experience with what you received. Just not sure what to do. The texture is definitely different with this bottle. More of a oil feel then the lightness of the others. Hmmm...

Re: Question...Josie M argon milk

expatgal — Tue, 25 Nov 2014 19:21:58 GMT

I've used approximately 6 bottles of this and never had a ""yellow"" one. I would definitely return it. I sure hope this doesn't start happening because I love this product.

Re: Question...Josie M argon milk

MarR — Tue, 25 Nov 2014 23:53:57 GMT

Thank you expatgal. I will return. My other ones were never this color. Hmmm...just received my tsv and the argon oil is partially frozen from the cold. Hope that is okay. Oh boy, what a few days I have been having. Giggle. Love Josie's products though! Thank you both again!

Re: Question...Josie M argon milk

QPrincess — Wed, 26 Nov 2014 00:25:08 GMT

I wish she would do a jumbo size so it would be more affordable.

Re: Question...Josie M argon milk

CoffeeTalk — Wed, 26 Nov 2014 04:20:08 GMT

Hmmmm...was wondering this myself. I just finished my TSV bottle which was bright white, and I loved it! So, I went to Sephora to buy another bottle and noticed the tester had a yellow tinge to it and the product looked like it was separating. I opened the box of a new bottle to check, and sure enough it was yellow and separating as well. And, there were stickers on the boxes saying something like all natural, shake well. I decided not to buy it until I did some research on how the milk should really look...confusing to have seemingly two different formulas floating around.

Re: Question...Josie M argon milk

Sweetiepie2 — Wed, 26 Nov 2014 04:25:54 GMT

On 11/25/2014 QPrincess said:
I wish she would do a jumbo size so it would be more affordable.

I just got this in a TSV and LOVE it but cancelled auto-delivery due to price. I LOVE the Argan milk but need a MUCH better value to order again!!!!!! Just to expensive for my budget right now. I would love a huge bottle with a good price.

Re: Question...Josie M argon milk

MarR — Wed, 26 Nov 2014 04:45:42 GMT

Thanks for all of the comments. I have it on auto so going to return this one and see what the next one is like. I did shake it and still not white like the others. A lot of money for not being sure. I don't like to have to return things but I would rather do that than worry something is wrong with it. Have a fabulous Thanksgiving. Hugs...

Re: Question...Josie M argon milk

bunjetto — Wed, 26 Nov 2014 05:29:09 GMT

I stated I do not know that I like the first bottle I purchased over the TSV bottle. I take it back ... I liked the not so white better than the new one. Yes you do have to shake the bottle. The original bottle I bought was much smoother, creamier (if that is a word) and the one I received in the TSV is chalky white and the texture is not creamy. I am sure the batches vary but these two were pretty different. Does your bottle mix when you shake it? and is it a creamy consistency? If so I would keep that bottle.

Re: Question...Josie M argon milk

Jump4joy2 — Wed, 26 Nov 2014 05:40:03 GMT

On 11/25/2014 bunjetto said:
I purchased the Milk when it first came out that bottle was off white and creamy. I then got the TSV with the Milk and this one is bright white and a chalky texture. Not sure what to think. I do know that I liked the first bottle better than the TSV one. Sorry I couldn't help.

Same situation with me ... The argan oil in the TSV is definitely different than what I previously purchased. What gives?? So much for quality control! I may just cancel my AD.

Re: Question...Josie M argon milk

Crisso — Wed, 26 Nov 2014 05:51:40 GMT

Thanks for posting this. I was wondering the same thing myself. I bought my first bottle at Sephora and it was a creamy white. I made sure to shake it every time I used it. It remained this color until yesterday. It is now ""yellow-ish"" and the product separates more easily. I wonder if this is exposure to air (oxygen) with every use and/or if the bottle is too light colored for this product to remain consistent....

Re: Question...Josie M argon milk

MarR — Thu, 27 Nov 2014 04:11:41 GMT

Okay, now I am thinking of keeping it after reading more of your comments. To know this happened to others makes me think it will be okay. Just different color and texture. Oh decisions decisions. Giggle. Just costs so much I want to make sure I am getting what I paid for. Wish Josie herself saw these posts and she could comment on this to help us all out. Reassuring that all is good and explain why the differences in color and texture. Couldn't get to the post office today as my dad is in hospital. Will make the decision on Friday. Happy Thanksgiving all and thanks for your comments! Hugs...