topic Re: Does Anyone Do This? in Beauty

Does Anyone Do This?

BeautyJunkie — Wed, 04 Jun 2014 16:48:37 GMT

My friend posted this article on Facebook by PBS. Does anyone follow these guidelines? I have a TON of stuff to throw out now. Does Mineral makeup last any longer?? And I'm assuming blush is the same as the eyeshadow dates?

"Many women are guilty of keeping makeup past its prime, whether it's a favorite lipstick or more dramatic, special-occasion eyeshadow. And though the FDA doesn't require cosmetics to have a printed expiration date, beauty products have a definite shelf life, says Ron Robinson, a cosmetic chemist and founder ofBeautyStat.com, who offers the following expiration guidelines:

Mascara: 3 to 6 months
Eyeliner: 3 to 6 months
Eyeshadow: 3 to 6 months
Lipstick: 1 year
Face powder: 1 year

"After that time, [makeup] is more at risk for growing bacteria or mold — especially if not closed tightly, and kept in a cool, dry environment," says Robinson. In a 2010 report, ABC News tested past-its-prime makeup and found 11 different types of bacteria, including staph, strep, and bacteria normally found in our intestinal system. Pay special attention to eye makeup and eye creams that are packaged in pots — they are more susceptible to contamination, Robinson says. "The eye area contains mucous membranes which are an entry point for possible infection," he advises.

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

vermint — Wed, 04 Jun 2014 16:58:59 GMT

The only one I'm a stickler about is mascara...I replace that every 3 months. I don't use expensive mascara for that very reason.

Lipsticks get tossed if they don't smell right.

I don't use "wet" eyeliners, so I'm not too concerned about those.

Pressed products get tossed when they start to look "old".

Mineral powders never get thrown away, unless I decide I don't like a color!

I've never had any kind of eye infection or any other problem.

Gosh, when I think that my Mom & I used to share ALL of our makeup! My friends & I also thought nothing of borrowing each others lipsticks & mascaras---not to mention hairbrushes/combs. This was late 60's early 70's, everyone I knew shared stuff. Somehow we survived!

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

Wackers3 — Wed, 04 Jun 2014 17:08:30 GMT

Cosmetic companies will be ecstatic over these time frames - think of the repeat buying potential. It is alarming when they test products and find those kind of germs. There is one advantage of living in a very dry climate - we are not as prone to the growth of certain bacteria who prefer humid arenas but we're not immune either.

I do keep everything well covered and in a draw. Am wondering how powders like Halo fare since it is well protected underneath the shaver plate and only fresh ground powder is applied to the face.

I would think blush would be in the same category as face powder - the eye products seem to have a shorter shelf life due to their being used in the eye area. Blush is used and applied like face powders so I'm more convinced they have a 1 year shelf life based on his criteria.

Cream blushes might be more susceptible then powder blushes however~.

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

theatrebiz — Wed, 04 Jun 2014 17:20:27 GMT

I follow about the same as vermint...

I replace mascara in that window - as it's usually starting to get clumpy anyway.

mineral make-up - no

eyeliner - since I am frequently shave the end, I don't see how it could grow bacteria - so I usually use them until they are done or dry out.

Lip stuff - my cue to toss is if the consistency changes or it's dry or doesn't smell right

Michele

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

just bee — Wed, 04 Jun 2014 17:26:06 GMT

Just my mascara. Three months and I toss it.

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

sun8shine — Wed, 04 Jun 2014 20:34:41 GMT

I do pitch mascara (but I am happy with a drugstore brand and it tend to use it up in 3 -4 mos)

The others - no

Wayne Goss has talked about products to sterilize your make up http://www.beautysoclean.com/ but I don't know if we can get it here in the States

Edit_ there is an online store for the US

I do clean my brushes frequently with rubbing alcohol to sterilize them (this works about 1000% better than washing your brushes with soap and they don't lose their shape and it is pretty cheap)

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

DoneTryin — Wed, 04 Jun 2014 20:38:12 GMT

Mascara - yes, because I use it more than anything else.

I keep mineral products forever; never use lipstick/gloss.

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

BeautyJunkie — Wed, 04 Jun 2014 22:48:55 GMT

Thanks ladies. I have a lifetime supply of Bare Minerals that I would hate to toss out, so it's good to know that that I can keep it! I think I'll be more diligent about my eye makeup and with everything else I'll toss if it smells or looks funny. I also need to be better about washing my makeup brushes.

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

Andreatoo — Thu, 05 Jun 2014 00:16:43 GMT

since the eyeliners were only a dollar a piece on sale I'm not too concerned if I have to toss them but I think there is something to the shaving off the ends idea anyway. I've been following the three month rule with the mascara

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

Pook — Thu, 05 Jun 2014 00:21:27 GMT

Most of the products I use only last about that amount of time anyway since I do my makeup daily and not just occasionally.

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

Porcelain — Thu, 05 Jun 2014 00:40:28 GMT

I keep some of my makeup way longer than I ought to. Cool but not daily-wearable lip colors and eyeshadow kits especially. But if it looks or smells or lays down weird, toss.

Seems to me that when you sharpen a makeup pencil, you are working with clean fresh(ish) product. It's a matter of whether any oil in the item has gone off. If you keep powder products dry and closed up, they should stay good for quite a while. Mascara dries out on me too fast for it to get old.

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

ginabfly — Thu, 05 Jun 2014 01:00:32 GMT

I judge each item by how it looks or performs. To me it's usually pretty obvious when something has gone bad. Powder shadows or blushes harden and stop giving pigment or are discolored, same with eye liners, they harden and don't glide on anymore. Lipstick and gloss changes texture and color. Liquid foundation separates or smells bad. Mascara is one that I usually do toss after a few months, especially if it starts to dry out or get clumpy. If I'm using it ever day, some get clumpy and dry out faster than 3 months.

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

myshell624 — Thu, 05 Jun 2014 01:07:21 GMT

Only mascara. I toss it after about 3-4 months.

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

LuluOnBeauty — Thu, 05 Jun 2014 01:22:39 GMT

Heavens, no!

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

Tinkrbl44 — Thu, 05 Jun 2014 01:25:50 GMT

I have a very strict hard and fast rule .........

I NEVER keep any makeup item longer than twenty years!

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

Irshgrl31201 — Thu, 05 Jun 2014 01:35:03 GMT

Just my mascara. Powder products I will keep for much longer. I have blush in my makeup drawers that is from 2005 I think.

Liquid products I keep a closer eye on though. I may have some liquid foundations that are maybe a year old but I don't keep them much longer than that and I haven't had a problem.

I have so many products that there is no possible way is H E L L that I could use them up that quickly.

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

Clover29 — Thu, 05 Jun 2014 01:43:36 GMT

On 6/4/2014 Tinkrbl44 said:
I have a very strict hard and fast rule .........

I NEVER keep any makeup item longer than twenty years!

We just moved house and I found some lipsticks in an old handbag that are at least 15 years old. The colors were discontinued and I thought I'd lost them a long time ago. It was like meeting an old friend, I was delighted to see them again. They smell just fine.

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

lovesrecess — Thu, 05 Jun 2014 01:56:56 GMT

I think some of these timelines are just to make sure we toss and have to buy more. I wear mostly LG and it is baked and lasts forever even when I use it daily.....I toss mascara when it gets clumpy in the tube and lipstick when it no longer goes on without dragging.

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

gazelle77 — Thu, 05 Jun 2014 02:08:02 GMT

On 6/4/2014 Tinkrbl44 said:
I have a very strict hard and fast rule .........

I NEVER keep any makeup item longer than twenty years!

Thank goodness I am not alone....I have bare minerals from WAY back that I stocked up on...lipsticks I only toss if they smell bad... The only thing I toss more often is mascara....but that is all!

Re: Does Anyone Do This?

silkyk — Thu, 05 Jun 2014 15:44:27 GMT

I just give it the sniff test. If toss that sucker and get some fun new stuff.