Re: FYI: Mally's Shadow Sticks have been discontin... - Page 2

HappyDaze · ‎06-13-2012

If they are like those Extra ones in the 5 pc set, they aren't very good. They do not stay on like the old formulas. I won't be buying anymore of them if they are changing them all to the Extra formula.

Tinkrbl44 · ‎08-23-2010

Oh kwap !!!

mimi5775 · ‎03-10-2010

I'm not buying from sweet Mallly anymore these days. Just not too crazy about anthing in the line I have tried - just don't reach for what i own of hers but I have so many other brands I tend to go to...I admit she has a great thing with her midnight liner! so smooth...but found others ...yet love hers most I think. I just think things will not be sticking around and I get to love products and want to repurchase.

I've learned to enjoy 3 of her eye stix but own Laura Mercier's and BB's and like BB's shades better some are more matte (one of Mally's color sticks is so pretty).. I won't miss those sparkles (most are way to sparkly!). I hope Mally succeeds, I enjoy her but even like Laura Geller being a smaller business (well larger then Mally's) they go discontinuing products too often - will own maybe 2 of hers and Mally's due to that.

I'm sticking with products and m/u that seems to be selling a long time.

My son went to Heaven 4/15/2018
I love and miss him so very much. God Bless you my dear Nicky

Campion · ‎10-21-2011

I still like her mascara best of anyone's--but I found I prefer Too Faced Eyeshadows to hers (for blendability) and I ended up loving Bare Escentuals foundation more than Laura Geller or IT. I've tried quite a few lines and ended up with a set of faves from each. IT has great CC++ cream with SPF for summer, Mally has great mascara and Too Faced has the best shadows.

The Mally Sticks were too shimmery--I hope the new ones will be to your liking. I'm sure she will continue them.

I got a new sort of shadow stick from Bare Escentuals in the last TSV, which I really like (a kit where I use every single item.) The stick goes on with that cream-to-liquid feel and it's a beautiful taupe like Mally makes, only not as shimmery. I hope they make more colors as I just LOVE this shadow stick. It's great for quick makeup--stroke it on and you have an eye look. Done.

Lipstickdiva · ‎03-10-2010

Backe when QVC had the New Beauty Test Tube, a full-size Mally shadow stick was included in one of the tubes. I absolutely loved it. It went on nicely and lasted on me all day. I used it from lashline to just above my brow bone.

However, I thought they were expensive and a stick didn't last long when I used it daily.