Mally's Six Pack of Mascara

I bought the 6 pack of Mally mascara, which is offered twice a year. From the first tube, I found the mascara caused clumping and I did not like the applicator. I decided to give it a try since it seemed to be highly rated. I used the first tube for the normal 3-month perod. Each tube got progressively worse, and after tube 2, I wasn't happy with the product. I opened tube 3 and it was dried out and had to throw it out immediately. The same applied to tubes 5 and 6. All of them dried out and the purchase was a bust. I'm thinking about going back to L'Oreal. The $60.00 I spent was no bargain. Maybe there are others who have had better luck, but Mally's mascara did nothing for me. I am disappointed.