116 Members and 18884 Guests Online

Kitchen & Food Talk

Are The Pies Good At Costco?

Started 1351329574.227 in Kitchen & Food Talk | Last reply 1351451447.547 by MopsyGirl

I just started going there and would like to pick up some pies. Would you recommedn Costco for pies? I love pumpkin.

Page 1 of 1
jasbel1351330105.582424 PostsRegistered 10/21/2008

I thought they were tasty... They are also huge, so not something I buy often. :)

cuddlesmama1351330500.014231 PostsRegistered 11/1/2005

I wanted to buy a couple for Thanskgiving

birkinbaby1351331552.6076017 PostsRegistered 1/20/2011


spud1881351332957.957643 PostsRegistered 9/23/2010

I bought a pumpkin pie last week it was so delishous..no way I could make a pie that big myself for $6.Their apple pie is so good too.

SeasonedCi­tizen1351334931.843244 PostsRegistered 10/9/2011

Bought a pecan pie at a Dallas Costco last year while I was visiting my DH and her husband in Okla and her MIL who is very picky went ballistic over it. Can't go wrong with anything in their bakery.

DiamondGir­ly1351335139.512620 PostsRegistered 9/7/2009Sunny California

Their pumpkin pies are great! They MUST use the Libby recipe, because it tastes just like what we make at home! (in my opinion)

Their apple pies are beautiful, but the ones I've had - the apples are still crunchy. I'm not sure if this is the usual, or not. I like my apples cooked all the way in pies.

Their Cheesecake is great, too!!

Almost everything in their bakery is wonderful!


Buon Appetito!!
Glori in Cali
Go San Francisco 49ers & GIANTS!!!

violann1351338808.44313935 PostsRegistered 12/12/2004
Our Costco used to sell unbaked apple pies around the holidays. Do any of them still do that? They were almost as good as my mom's homemade pies, and much better than mine.

I didn't come here to argue.- Peg Bracken

shell871351346683.41710 PostsRegistered 9/18/2012Missouri

I buy pumpkin pie every year for Thanksgiving at Costco, and usually pecan, too. They are both delicious! I like the pumpkin because it's so big, it can serve quite a few people. Much easier and better than making it at home. Smile

RocketMom1351347590.32763 PostsRegistered 9/23/2007

All Costco bakery items are great, including the pies!

sillybugs1351347685.197765 PostsRegistered 8/8/2009

They pumpkin are very good. Also, last year at Thanksgiving a family member brought a pie with berries in it to dinner, sorry don't remember the name, it was also very good.

Skin: Combo/mild seborrheic dermatitis around sides of nose/forehead, sensitive/reactive, fine lines just starting around eyes.
Hair: Salt & pepper, normal, mild seborrheic dermatitis on scalp, shoulder length bob.

Andrewsgra­ndma1351347769.21772 PostsRegistered 9/2/2006Phx

Their pies are delicious and you just cant beat the prices. We get a pumpkin and caramel apple pie every thanksgiving and Christmas.Their other baked goods are yummy too. Cant go wrong with their birthday cakes.

cuddlesmama1351359418.7474231 PostsRegistered 11/1/2005

Thank you so much. I'll be buying my pumkin pie at Costcos this year!

hulagirl1351359675.4577802 PostsRegistered 10/6/2004

Costco pies are really good........I loved just about everything in that place!!

icuryy1351360221.86613 PostsRegistered 6/15/2010

OMG these are soo worth it. Their pumpkin is just like a homemade pie and why bother when it is just as tasty. Last year I missed out on their Apple/Cranberry pie as they were all sold out. That was also very tasty. Do yourself a favor and buy the pies there and that gives you more free time as holidays can be stressful enough. Enjoy!!!

queendiva1351360484.493943 PostsRegistered 9/22/2006

Costco's pumpkin pie and apple pie are TDF. Always buy my Thanksgiving pies there.

The quality and value for the pies is unbeatable. I no longer bake pies- I buy Costco.

ALTECHNET1351440439.313725 PostsRegistered 10/30/2010USA

Make sure you check the expire date. Otherwise you'll get a stale old pie or cake. They push these to their members. When fresh or just bake the pies and cake are not like the old time bake shops use to be. Look on the label to what is put into the cake, pie or cookies. To much chemicals, natural flavor (avoid because it chemical base). Auntie's Organic USDA Pies, cakes or cookies are much better and found in the frozen section of most supermarkets. Costco, BJs and SamsClub needs to carries these products.

Windows Client / Server OS and Android OS Expert

JeanLouise­Finch1351441522.2412973 PostsRegistered 10/3/2011

The Costco Pumpkin Pie is a winner. It's huge and an excellent value.

I know you probably are asking about dessert pies, but I have to add a thumbs up for their Chicken Pot Pie, too. It's not really all that good for you, but it's a delicious comfort food on occasion nonetheless.

dmqshopper1351448441.431533 PostsRegistered 7/18/2009

Yes, they are yummy.

amartinezf­an1351448883.889630 PostsRegistered 12/1/2006Sunny San Diego

You don't realize how large they are in the store. Then when you get it home you have to figure out where to put it. HUGE!

Chicagoan1351449431.332699 PostsRegistered 6/11/2008CHICAGOLAND
On 10/27/2012 JR said:

Their pies are delicious and you just cant beat the prices. We get a pumpkin and caramel apple pie every thanksgiving and Christmas.Their other baked goods are yummy too. Cant go wrong with their birthday cakes.

Wow... I didn't know that Costco also sold the "Caramel Apple Pie", I have bought it from Sam's Club a couple of years ago and it was TDF. I will be checking out Costco's version. Thanks for the heads up!

Robin ....

Midlife is the time we begin “to listen with our ♥ heart.”

MopsyGirl1351451447.5432576 PostsRegistered 2/15/2008

I love their pumpkin pie! I don't like the apple pie for the same reason another poster mentioned - crunchy apples. I like mine soft and cooked through.

Page 1 of 1