Shoes & Handbags Offers
123 Members and 12077 Guests Online

Beauty Banter

Mally's eyeliner

Started 1355433597.607 in Beauty Banter | Last reply 1355589339.343 by PUMPKIN

I had to laugh when I watched her TSV and how on her hand she could rub all day and the liner doesn't move. Well, put it on your eyelid and watch it move! I have to wear Dermablend setting powder in order to have her eyeliner not be all over the eye area. Anyone else feel the same way?

Page 1 of 1
Mirage081355434004.862845 PostsRegistered 1/16/2009

LOL! Oh I do. I have a few of her liners. I gave away a few to a friend. I keep the colored ones (purple, navy, green, etc). Not "bullet proof" on me at all. I'm trying to use them up.

Nascardiva13554341586537 PostsRegistered 6/27/2005Maryland

It's all trickery with the rubbing of the hand; just remember that the hand is quicker than the eye, and she really isn't rubbing the eyeliner.

I'm a true redhead - with the color comes the temper.
Beauty gets the attention but personality gets the heart.

Lanikins1355437083.761447 PostsRegistered 6/13/2009

I believe that she's really rubbing the liners on her hand, but that's just it -- they are on her hand and not on the eye. Oil from your eyelids causes the liner to bleed.

winamac11355437196.930436 PostsRegistered 12/29/2010Indiana

I love Mally, but her liners are NOT bulletproof at all. Too Faced waterproof and Tarte's new liners are better and softer and stay on longer. They are easier to get on than Mallys too. Hers are far from waterproof or bulletproof.

"Friends don't let friends...drink white zinfandel"

RedConvert­ibleGirl1355437274.20313987 PostsRegistered 9/3/2005Pacific NW

I've done that demo on my hand at home and they do not come off. I have to scrub hard with a wet wash cloth to get it off. I love her eye liners, they last all day. They perform exactly as she says.

When we shoulder the mantle of compassion no cry goes unheard and no wound goes unhealed. In this world of seemingly endless suffering we have to believe that no one is beyond hope of rescue. Scotlund Haisley, Animal Rescue Corps

loveschoco­late13554374899704 PostsRegistered 5/11/2012Ohio......GO BUCKS!!!!
Not "bulletproof" for me.

"Chocolate should be one of the major food groups!"

"I've learned so much from my mistakes...I'm thinking of making a few more!"

lovereruns1355446372.52766 PostsRegistered 10/6/2004

Red convertible girl - I'm so surprised that the eye liners last on you. I was so happy when I first saw her demo and the liner went on great and then after about a half day, I looked in the mirror and could not believe that it was "moving". Yes, they stay on my hand great and I too had to scrub to get it off, but the eye area is so different. I wish she could rub the eye area on TV to show what happens. Thanks to all who have commented.

Alsee1355456302.2072429 PostsRegistered 11/21/2006
Doesn't work for me either. Ended up all over my lid. I like BE or Physicians Formula, which is very inexpensive and wears all day

BellaCarro1355456645.4977944 PostsRegistered 10/1/2011Atlanta
On 12/13/2012 RedConvertibleGirl said:

I've done that demo on my hand at home and they do not come off. I have to scrub hard with a wet wash cloth to get it off. I love her eye liners, they last all day. They perform exactly as she says.

I recently rec'd the 10 e/l library (20% off, no s&h at beauty dot com) and they perform beautifully on me too. Love them.

quesolvr1355456865.65232 PostsRegistered 9/9/2011

It is not just about the liner, it is about what you use under it. Do you use a thick eye cream for day? They are emoliant and will break down makeup. Save it for night. Ue something lightweight for day, I like dermalogica multi vit for eye. Or an eye gel. Do you use an eye shadow primer? Do you set all your cream products with a similar shade in powder? You really only need to do that one if you are very oily or have watery eyes.

KatCat11355456963.99716846 PostsRegistered 7/21/2011

I purchased her concealer a couple years ago. It was not bulletproof. I never went back for seconds.

Cosmetics_­Crazy1355459882.2071094 PostsRegistered 5/21/2011
On 12/13/2012 RedConvertibleGirl said:

I've done that demo on my hand at home and they do not come off. I have to scrub hard with a wet wash cloth to get it off. I love her eye liners, they last all day. They perform exactly as she says.


Yes, I have done the same and had to scrub quite hard as well to get them off. I have the same result with my eyes, wear all day and they dont budge.

The new ones (white with twist up) are my favorite, they go on so soft and creamy and once they set they are there for the duration.

tototwo1355489318.5932520 PostsRegistered 2/8/2008Great Plains

Mally's eyeliners last all day on me and don't move or smudge -- in fact, I have a difficult time removing them at night.

However, I don't like them because they don't glide on smoothly. They get clumps and I have to use short strokes pull really hard to make an even line - and I don't like pulling hard around my eyes! So I quit wearing them.

If you obey all the rules, you miss all of the fun.
- Katharine Hepburn

kabella1355494980.6073951 PostsRegistered 1/30/2012

I had Mally's eyeliner & it was bulletproof but I prefer Maybelline eye stilletto, great staying power & prefer the tip for easier application.

RedConvert­ibleGirl1355525413.9513987 PostsRegistered 9/3/2005Pacific NW
On 12/14/2012 tototwo said:

Mally's eyeliners last all day on me and don't move or smudge -- in fact, I have a difficult time removing them at night.

However, I don't like them because they don't glide on smoothly. They get clumps and I have to use short strokes pull really hard to make an even line - and I don't like pulling hard around my eyes! So I quit wearing them.

Did you use the twist up ones or the ones you sharpen? Both have worked for me, but I find the ones you sharpen to be very creamy and easy - no tugging or pulling at all. They just glide across the lid.

When we shoulder the mantle of compassion no cry goes unheard and no wound goes unhealed. In this world of seemingly endless suffering we have to believe that no one is beyond hope of rescue. Scotlund Haisley, Animal Rescue Corps

tototwo1355588373.222520 PostsRegistered 2/8/2008Great Plains

Red ~ I have 2 of the twist-up pencils. I've never tried the Mally pencils that you sharpen. Now that I've been using the Jordana twist-up eyeliners, I won't be buying Mally or any other brand. I'm hooked on Jordana for $1.99 at Walgreens!!

If you obey all the rules, you miss all of the fun.
- Katharine Hepburn

PUMPKIN1355589300.027553 PostsRegistered 4/14/2006Indiana
Worst eyeliner for all reasons above. Live Mally's mascara though.

PUMPKIN1355589339.343553 PostsRegistered 4/14/2006Indiana
Oops. Love the mascara!

Page 1 of 1