135 Members and 20880 Guests Online

Beauty Banter


Started 1283633731.837 in Beauty Banter | Last reply 1283661777.563 by drkcharger

Can anyone tell me which eyeliner stays on best?Especially for the inner eye rim.I take meds that make me sweat really bad at times. I'd love to find a liner that stays more than an hour. I did order and try Smashbox Jet Set Gel Eyeliner.It came with the brush and was supposed to be waterproof but for me it wasn't any better than the ones I get at the drugstore. PLEASE HELP!!I really need an eyeliner with staying power.I don't look as sick either when I can keep my eyes defined.Thanks for any info!{#emotions_dlg.blink}

with warmest regards to my QVC sistas, Billie

Page 1 of 1
SherbearTwo1283634499.2171529 PostsRegistered 2/3/2009

Urban Decay 24/7 liners are the best. I have them in several colors, but use the black for the inner r i m.

Also, MAC kohl pencils stay on my water line better than their waterproof liners. MUFE aqua liners are good too. Stila, Revlon color stay, and Sephora's kohl waterproof liners are good too.

There are so many, but these are the pencils I go to the most. I have also used BB gel liner and it's ok, but I prefer a pencil. Do not like Smashbox.

Hope this helps....

Jayro1283635429.2471996 PostsRegistered 11/29/2008

I like Mac Fluidline in Dipdown, a dark brown matte.

TooManyCats1283641906.692694 PostsRegistered 7/5/2009

I just got Tarte's Inner Rim Eyeliner in a kit. I only tried it quickly, not for a full day yet, but you would hope with that name it'd be right along the lines of what you're looking for!

grannyjann­ie1283642022.728724 PostsRegistered 11/17/2006West of the Windy City

I find it hard to believe that ANY liner will stay put for long periods of time. Everything wears off on me, and I'm not an 'oily skin'.....

Hopeless Romantic :)

CAshopper2­0111283644312.0073745 PostsRegistered 12/20/2009
I agree that the MAC kohl stays on really well inner rim. I tried this as a cheaper alternative to laura Mercier kohl which also works well for my inner lid. I think it would definitley be worth a try but it might not work if nothing works for you.

winamac1283644387.8419053 PostsRegistered 8/21/2005Carmel, Indiana
On 9/4/2010 grannyjannie said:

I find it hard to believe that ANY liner will stay put for long periods of time. Everything wears off on me, and I'm not an 'oily skin'.....


BE has a buxom one that isn't bad and Tarte has one that isn't too bad. But, they all wear off.

DCShopper1283645481.9569 PostsRegistered 9/2/2007

Hello! I like Mally Beauty eyeliners and I line the upper and lower inner rims--looks like my eyelashes are naturally thick. They stay put for me. I have severe allergies to dust and my eyes water--a lot around my office. The eyeliner does not move, run or burn my eyes and looks bright.

WOB1283653119.296 PostsRegistered 9/4/2010

I have recently discovered the new Cover Girl liquilineblast pencils, and they are FANTASTIC! They stay on all day, inner rim and along the lashes...you can't go wrong!

nckjm1283653786.137828 PostsRegistered 7/20/2009NC

I have good success with both Smashbox and Mally pencils...and both are safe for inner rims. Have not tried the others mentioned here...I am on auto-delivery with Smashbox kit with jet set liner so I won't be needing any additional for a l-o-n-g time.

My3Girls1283656956.3347 PostsRegistered 1/26/2008

I recently discovered POP inliner which was recommended by the board here. I tried black, it's easy to apply (top and bottom rims) and lasts for several hours. What I like is that I do not have racoon eyes by the end of the day. The liner may have faded but it's not below my eyes making me look tired so it's a winner.

I'm going to try smashbox limitless waterproof eyeliners next and will have to see how they work.

I did try Loreal HIP eye crayon years ago and since it's a fat crayon it's not the easiest to apply but dang it stayed on all day. Problem is i can't find these anymore.

If the SM limitless eyeliners won't work, I think I'm going to get a few more colors of the POP inliners.

drkcharger1283661777.563777 PostsRegistered 2/17/2005

I was the one who posted about the In-Liner buy pop cosmetics as it is specifically for the inner rim. I have tried all the above for this part of the eye and they don't stay on well.

Ulta is now carrying them

Page 1 of 1